McHenry’s Irish Pub

Excellent fresh not pre prepared dishes pleasant environment lots of tv’s plenty of beer and liquor choices highly recommended

Good burger, with real meat, instead of a squished frozen pattie. Nice soup too.
Would have been another star, but for the service. Paid in cash. No coins in the change. And missing a $ 5. The $ 5 was provided when I showed tht it was missing. Eventually. Hopefully it was just an honest mistake, but I was made to feel as if I had pocketed the bill:(

Stopped in for a snack. Hub and I shared a basket of wings, a side of steamed broccoli, and a shrimp basket. Everything was perfectly cooked, served nice and warm and seasoned exactly right. Delicious, and we will definitely do again.

have been there twice. the food was good for bar fare. had a shrimp po boy, only had 5 shrimp not enough for the money. second trip we had the potato skins which were awesome. we then ordered 3 different chicken. wings, all very meaty priced fair and the best I have had recently.wouldrecommend.

Been there several times, keep hoping the food will improve since we are locals. Guess not. Frozen, out of a box off the truck bar food. Come here to socialize, not to eat a meal.

Wasn’t sure what to expect. Party of nearly 20 peeps and the service was EXCELLENT! We had burgers, sandwiches, shrimp, soup & salad, and more. Food was AWESOME! Highly recommend and can’t wait to go back!

One of my favorites, hand’s down best wings ever! If your not into wings they make a great steak and cheese, great fish and chips, hey all the food is great! In my opinion best place in surrounding area. Service is friendly, place is clean and fun atmosphere to hang with the locals would give 5 stars but sometimes service lacks, maybe being a former restaurant owners ourselves we are a little more critical in that department. In the area check them out you won’t be disappointed! :)

Phenomenal find great service and food most try the cuban truly authentinc made by a Cuban chef ! and the philly lets not forget will defenitely be back for more great job guys!

McHenry’s came very highly recommended by my family, so I had to check it out while in the town of Melrose and Keystone Heights. They seem to be popular, with the parking lot almost completely full by the time we left after eating dinner here. They recently expanded with more room in the back for larger parties, as well as an outside area. Great atmosphere with a small town vibe.
Service was okay, all were waitresses around college age, but appeared to have a bit of waitressing experience.
I do not really understand what makes this an Irish Pub, since the brews and food offered are not different than any other sports bar. We ordered many items; clam strips on crinkle fries, fried green bean appetizer, fried okra appetizer, and hot wings mixed with garlic parmesan. The wings are naked fried— and yeah, basically everything was fried. Except for the celery sticks that come with the wings. I saw some other tables ordered salads, which looked really fresh, not just iceberg lettuce.
The main thing that stood out to me is their homemade dressings and sauces; ranch, tartar sauce, and blue cheese were homemade and really good.
The fried green beans and okra, were almost $ 7 each per basket— so the total added up to $ 70+ for a party of five people very quick. We all had sodas, and one person had a beer, but that’s it.

Excellent food and friendly service. Burger and wings are the best in the area. Two dozen new draft beers have been added to a large beer choice. Owner is very community friendly, always the first with a donation to a cause. Put this at the end of a poker run. You won’t be disappointed.

Ask them to put garlic in the hot wings sauce. I’ve been here a few times and the food is always excellent. It’s privately owned.

Not very Irish other than some Guinness mirrors and such on the wall but, the food we had on this visit was really good. I got a cheeseburger with bacon and grilled onions and my buddy got an order of wings. We were both happy and frankly, somewhat surprised. Dining options in Keystone are rather limited and I would list McHenry’s as a solid choice.
Service was friendly though a bit slow and it’s a little scary for the future when the manager comes around saying you will get a 10% discount on your bill if you pay with cash. The biggest negative was all the Orange and Blue clad Gator fans there watching football but, I don’t hold that against McHenry’s as that money spends too. Go Noles! :)

Plenty of Irish whiskey available but not much Irish beer other than Guinness (draft). Large selection otherwise. Very pleasant, airy interior. Very pleasant airy waitress. Great menu for a sports bar, especially for this little town. Hope it makes it because the Philly Cheese steak sandwich was the best I’ve ever had (including some in Philly). Prices reasonable. Wings were pretty good too. We sat in the bar but I think it had a section that was restaurant only sort of thing that might be quieter.