8th Ave Pizza

First time having this amazing pizza. We were blown away. We were leery of ordering because of some of the reviews. Holy cow were they wrong. This place is awesome! Yes, delivery is generally an hour. Plan accordingly. Yes, when you add fresh garlic you’re going to get GARLIC! I can see how some would think there’s too much. We love garlic so there’s no such thing. It was perfect for us. Yes, it’s pricier than Pizza Hut. But there’s a reason! Worth every penny!

Pizza was just ok if you like thin crust. Chicken fingers with ranch were pretty good and I liked their steak fries. My salad was a chicken Caesar and was made with some wilted iceberg lettuce, not too good but the ranch, which was $ 1 extra was pretty good. They got us for $ 50 which was very overpriced so we probably will not be going back.

We ordered pizza from here because it was near my friend’s new home. Almost an hour after ordering delivery we had 3 crying young kids and no pizza. We called and checked the status and did mention we ordered «approximately an hour ago» only to be corrected that it had only been 50 minutes and it would be at least another 5. So we said, ok sounds good, and we waited another 10 minutes to get our cardboard pizza and over garlic laden breadsticks. Within minutes the entire house smelled of garlic and even though me and my friend love garlic, it was still too much for us. My kids, despite being hungry only ate half a slice of pizza because it was too greasy even after we paper toweled off much of it. I had one bite of flat breadstick, but the seasoning was way overdone and just gross. We actually THREW AWAY PIZZA.
Waste of money. Call another mom and pop shop if you’re looking for good service, timely delivery, and want to satisfy some taste buds! This place was a complete disappointment. Worst pizza ever.

These pizza is on point. Perfectly cooked, and just the right amount of cheese. High grade cheese used cause there is no grease. They have great wings and offer like 15 sauces to cover them in, similar to BWW. The ranch is amazing, no hidden valley here. My only issue with this place is the sizes of pizza they offer; it’s either a personal or a large, nothing in between. Will be back!

Meh. Cardboard pizza that delivers to Mountains Edge. We ordered a large supreme, personal cheese pizza, and 12 wings based strictly off of good reviews for this place, but we were just plain disappointed. First, it was $ 50 after delivery fees, credit card fee, and tip to the driver for a small amount of food. I would have been fine with the price if the pizza was delicious, but the pizza was mediocre at best. The second star comes for the second day when we reheated my daughter’s cheese pizza and it was better cooked again, compared to the night before. The hunt for good pizza in the southwest will continue, but seriously don’t bother going to Eighth Avenue Pizza if you like NY style pizza or Deep Dish Chicago Style Pizza, or pizza in general.

This place is amazing! the staff is very friendly.
Both times the pizza was cooked perfectly, exactly what we ordered.
Not sure if he was a manager or not but my first time there I was deciding what appetizer i wanted to try, I finally picked he charged me and when the food was ready he went ahead and gave me a free order of mozz sticks anyways to try.
The second time while I was waiting for my pizza the guy gave me and my fiancé a free soda.
The people hear give great customer service and the cooks are fantastic!

My family loves this place moved to southern highlands this year and this is the go to pizza place! Thin crust good sauce Good pizza period

We’ve tried a lot of pizza places and so far, 8^th Ave is the super best!!! Killer thin crispy pizza and honestly, the wings are out of this world — crispy and delicious. My husband’s favorite pizza ever is a place called Prima Pizza in Gilbert, AZ… This place is very close to that taste and flavor!!!

After 4yrs of living in southern highlands i finally tried this place. .i always forget about this pizza place and noticed it’s usually always empty. … i wasnt expecting my pizza to be thin crust, i ordered the Hawaiian pizza and 5pc «hot» buffalo wings. .
First my pizza was just ok… i dont really like thin pizzas it was again, just ok.
My wings weren’t even «hot» to be the buffalo hot wings, and the fries were bland :(
When i called to place my order i can relate to those reviews saying who ever answered had no emotion, but he wasn’t rude. I went to pick up my pizza, it was ready on time, i wanted to add a drink and the guy working gave me a free drink. .
Overall, i wont be back, maybe people that like thin crust pizzas will enjoy

Great pizza and service! Decided to give them a try after a horrible experience at another pizza place near by. Very glad we did! The pizza is thin crust and delicious. The staff was very attentive and friendly. We will definitely be back!

I ordered because I got a flyer and I was bored with the place I normally order from. I won’t order again for a few reasons. One I’m not a thin crust type of person. If you are then you might like it. Two, the grease was nasty! I soaked it up with a paper towel before I ate. Third, their prices are bananas! Not worth the cost in my opinion at all. They do have good ranch and steak fries. That’s about it. Sucks because I like supporting non-​chain places.

We are regulars at this place and live right down the street which makes this location so convenient for anyone living in Southern Highlands! Though many food spots have been opening up around the area, finding quality food and decent service are tough to find. Being a native New Yorker finding a good pizza is a struggle for me to put it lightly, but I’ve gotta say this place always consistently delivers a thin crispy crust on their pizza and great medium heat wings! I would definitely recommend this spot and they also send out coupons pretty often and take care of our soft drinks when we dine in. The majority of the staff is really friendly and welcoming.

Gave these guys a second chance tonight and I’m sorry I did. Ordered two pizzas and chicken fingers. First of all, their prices were raised from their already high prices for small pizzas.
They charged 50 cents to sub blue cheese for ranch and didn’t honor their usual large cheese pizza deal.
To top it… they screwed up my order… again. Ordered a plain cheese pizza for my picky son and it came in as a pepperoni. The second pizza did not have evenly distributed toppings.
On the phone, the guy justified the mistakes, did not say sorry, never offered money back and said he would only make a new cheese pizza to replace the pepperoni. He said I could come in to get it and did not offer to have it delivered. When I asked, he said it would be 45 minutes. I came in.
When I got there, again, no apology, no refund offer. I told him it would be my last time in here after giving them this second chance. We conversed for a minute and I left. I’m done with their overpriced, poorly prepared product.

Still a great little local pizza place. My family and I have been eating 8^th Ave Pizza regularly since my first review five years ago.
I believe I’ve only had one poor experience with the quality of pizza over the course of that time. Overall it is a very tasty good quality thin crust pizza. I don’t eat wings, but my husband loves them and gets them often. Also, just an FYI, the garlic sticks are crazy garlicky, almost like raw garlic.
The employees have never been over the top friendly, but I don’t think it’s such a big deal like some other reviewers seem to.
Yummy!

Solid tasting thin crest pizza that is consistent. Best pizza place in Southern Highlands. Like the other pizza places in the area, 8^th Ave I would say is an order and go place. Cannot really go wrong on any of their combinations. Good prices, and even the non-​pizza items satisfy.

I’m a new resident in Southern Highlands. 2 weeks ago my family tried this pizza restaurant and the food is very good. 8^th Ave is the best in town.

Just tried the new Caprice Pizza. Can’t wait to have it again!!! I would of expected to find a dish like this at a high-​end restaurant at high end prices, but here we have it! I was even surprised to have an order of thick cut fries with home made thick and creamy ranch and even garlic salt set on the table. A great place to grab a pizza in our Southern Highland area.

Im from the East Coast, so I have high expectations of my pizza. This place is good. Not GREAT, but I am happy to have a local small pizza shop that makes good pizza. We bought from here a few times. We got the white pizza, BBQ Chicken, and regular cheese pizza. All were good, but our favorite was the White pizza.
Pizzas are a little small, BUT the prices are reasonable for them, so you can just buy 2 for the price of 1 elsewhere.

Pizza is meh, not very good. Maybe appetizers are ok. I won’t be back, not worthwhile. I keep reading that the staff is rude but they were fine when I was there.

Rude assholes run this place. Pizza is ok .
Why all the rat traps outside the building? I wonder !!! If there are rats running around outside I’m sure a few have gotten inside too. Enjoy