Jeff’s Pizza Shop

Great pizza and bread sticks! Must try! Got the pizza and bread stick special today. Lots of food for the price. Will be back

Great lunch specials, both on sandwiches and the 10-​inch pizza. Good choice of toppings. They always have friendly service.

Good pizza. Good price. Short wait. Daily specials. Delivery. Well i guess thats about it. All in all good restaurant. Kids liked it. I will return.

Good food, good prices — if you use the lunch special.
I’ve eaten at Jeff’s several times recently to calibrate my opinion on the place. The pizza is good (not quite AJ’s level, IMO), and serving sizes are reasonable. Sauce isn’t sweet (which is a good thing), and the crust has a good flavor. The service is friendly but spotty — I usually end up refilling my own drinks. Prices can add up pretty quickly, but their current lunch special is a good deal — $ 6 for a 2-​topping 10″ or sandwich and drink.

Really great pizza and really great service. Everyone was super nice and our food was done pretty fast. Other reviews said it’s pricey but I’m from KCMO and pizza is a lot more there so it seemed like a great deal to me.

The food at Jeff’s is pretty great, especially for an Aggieville location, but it’s also pretty pricey. We’ve gotten delivery about two dozen times over the last few months, getting their wings, Smotherella sticks, pizzas, salads and subs. Everything has been great. The wings are huge — our favorite sauce is the Roasted Garlic BBQ. You don’t need a dipping sauce with it at all. Love the pizzas, though the larger sizes of thin crust can be very soggy in the middle. The subs are also great, and they’re huge, probably the best value on their menu. I love the salads but sometimes they show up without all the toppings that are supposed to be there, and on something like the Greek salad, it’s really noticeable. I’m not a fan of the breadsticks, personally, but there’s so much else there to get that it’s easy to skip the sticks.
For two people to get dinner it’s kind of expensive, though. Two subs, a small salad and a 10-​piece wings delivered is about $ 30 with tip. Two small pizzas and a 10-​piece wings will be more like $ 35. I hate to say this because I know drivers need tips but you can save a lot by eating in – no delivery charge and no tip to pay really adds up.
My only real complaint has been that the rewards system they have is wonky and has been for months, but they still haven’t fixed it. Got yelled at this summer for using «too many rewards» even though when I called to order, employees were telling me I had a rewards coupon on my account to redeem, so I would redeem it. Apparently I didn’t have coupons? All I know is the manager made some poor employee call me back one night and get rude and threatening, telling me I wasn’t going to get my free breadsticks and NEVER to use a reward coupon again. It’s funny in retrospect but at the time she was obviously upset and confused, and I was confused too. We avoided Jeff’s for months and when we ordered again, they kept offering us those rewards coupons, and I would have to almost yell at them to stop giving us discounts. I’m sure we sounded like crazy old people yelling at clouds. «Stop offering us discounts!» LOL
Finally one night we got a guy named Jeff who was very nice and explained it had been a technical problem, and yes, of course we could use our rewards coupons. Seriously, the entire episode was unnecessary and weird, and I’m still a little wary of the place, but the food is so good I’ll forgive a lot.

Place sucks. Ordered from them twice trying help a local business and it was horrible.

Awesome food, great staff, and good music and atmosphere. What’s more to ask for? I’d recommend this to anyone near aggieville KS.

This is the type of pizza that helps me sleep at night. I can go to bed knowing there’s things this delicious in the world.

Quite possibly the worst pizza in Manhattan. The flavor is lacking, the service was meh, the breadsticks were terrible. Avoid at all costs!

I stayed in a nearby hotel and was in the mood for pizza. Fast delivery and an excellent Midwestern style crust and pizza. I would recommend to any one staying in an area hotel that wants a great independent run pizza

When I first saw this place open in Aggieville, I didn’t expect much from it. From the outside it doesn’t look like much, and I’ve seen Aggieville pizza places come and go. However, I gave it a try, and I have to say that it might be the best pizza in Manhattan. The food is high quality, and they have a large menu that is both creative and allows lots of customization. Some of their unique pizza specialties include a gyro pizza, a baked potato pizza, and one featuring buffalo. The best thing on the menu are the manjare rolls, which are homemade bread and cheese perfection. Definitely forego the Bosco cheese sticks in favor of a ‘just cheese’ manjare, as they are way better. Jeff’s delivers and offers easy-​to-​use online ordering. This place is awesome and I hope it sticks around a long time!