My Daddy’s Pizza

Manhattan, United States

2.9

17 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 646-473-1760
Address:
976 6th Ave, Manhattan, NY, 10018
Midtown West
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
640 ft34th Street-Herald Square (B,D,F,M,N,Q,R)
0.2 miWashington Deluxe
0.2 mi33rd Street (PATH)
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good for Groups
No
Alcohol
No
Waiter Service
No

Today

Today –
Local time (Manhattan) 2:55 AM Thursday, May 29, 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Related places

Explore similar places:
370
ft
Stella 34 Trattoria
Macy's 6th Floor - 35th & Broadway Entrance 151 W 34th St (Midtown West)
430
ft
Cafe 37
47 W 37th St (Midtown West)
430
ft
Jerusalem Cafe
35 W 36th St (Midtown West)
440
ft
Mike’s Pizzeria & Cafe
35 W 36th St (Midtown West)
460
ft
Bombay Fast Food
1013 6th Ave (Midtown West)
460
ft
6th Avenue Pizza
1013 6th Ave (Midtown West)

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:
50
ft
Soheil Oriental Rugs
36 E 31st St Rm 703
70
ft
990 Av Americas Assocs
980 Avenue of the Americ
70
ft
Marcus Brothers Textiles
980 Avenue of the Americ
70
ft
Splat Ink
78 W 36th St
80
ft
5 Boro Burger
80 W 36th St
90
ft
Mc Donald’s
972 Ave of the Americas

17 reviews of My Daddy’s Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 3
ASTORIA, NY
It was a good place to get something quick especially Pizza. But this turned into a lounge now and I believe the name has also changed.
Place rating: 4
Manhattan, NY
closed down unfortunatly
Place rating: 4
St Paul, MN
Not incredible but quick and tasty with decent dinner specials…
Place rating: 3
Woodbridge Township, NJ
This is a pizza spot to remmeber. We were pretty hungry after we got of the 33rd street path stop and needed a quick bite. Rather than hit the tourist trap food courts we found this little pizza stand. They have tables set up outside so seating wasn’t a problem. Pizza was good, really good. No sign of a bathroom though. We will probably return to grab a slice before venturing further into the city in the future.
Place rating: 3
Madisonville, LA
I stopped on the way back to my room for a quick bite, I was surprised expecting it to be just ok, it was actually pretty good.
Place rating: 3
New Hope, PA
Surprisingly, I enjoyed this pizza. I tried 2 slices — one was called a «Roma» slice I believe (square pizza) which I enjoyed the most, but my slice of plain left something to be desired. Definitely not a good plain slice to NYC standards. Either way, I give it 3 stars because the specialty pie was good.
Place rating: 5
Pittsburgh, PA
I loved this pizza! My sister and I ate there twice because of how good it was when we stayed close-​by. She loved the buffalo chicken pizza and I loved the spinach mushroom pizza. I miss it already. Did not expect much by the looks of the establishment but was pleasantly surprised:-)
Place rating: 3
Houston, TX
This place was really close to my hotel so we decided to go grab a slice after sleeping in Monday morning. The pizza was OK, nothing to get excited about. They do offer a lot of variety and for that reason they get three stars.
Place rating: 4
Capistrano Beach, CA
Larry is the slim guy at the register. When I told him «never trust a skinny cook» he informed me that he’s down 100 lbs! He’s been a staple entrepreneur in the immediate vicinity so long he can tell you about when Macy’s was a vegetable garden. It certainly has given him sufficient time to perfect the pork pizza, try it… you’ll be so happy you indulged a little or A LOT!!!
Place rating: 1
Santa Fe, NM
The pizza was ok, but I had a pretty bad experience at this place.
I overheard the staff make a joke about me to each other, in Spanish, assuming I wouldn’t understand what they were saying. But I speak enough Spanish to get it. I told them angrily but politely, that it was pretty rude to make fun of your customers. They were obviously pretty shocked that I understood, and tried to pretend they weren’t talking about me.
When you pay $ 5 for one lousy slice of pizza, the least they can do is treat you with basic respect.
Place rating: 2
York, PA
Good crust but sauce and cheese were not memorable.
Place rating: 4
Essex, NJ
It must be because I’m from New Jersey and I don’t get to taste NY pizza often. Compared to what I’d had recently, My Daddy’s Pizza tasted darn good! Sorry, guys, this may not sound like much of a compliment but it is. I trust my taste buds. The sauce was awesome, not sweet at all. A lot of sauce has sugar added and I don’t like that sweet taste. The crust was not too doughy or thick, there was the right amount of cheese. I’d take a PATH ride just for 2 slices of that pizza again!
Place rating: 2
Queens, NY
I came here out of desperation, I was basically just looking for the nearest pizza sign. And I knew from the name and the location that I wasn’t in for anything good, and I got what I expected. It’s unsatisfying, mediocre pizza. But it’s not absolutely horrible, so there’s that I guess.
Place rating: 2
New York, NY
I wasn’t inspired or anything, just thought I’d write a review because I walk past this place every day, and it’s the closest pizza-​by-​the-​slice near me.
It’s surprising that there’s so much foot traffic in this area, yet nowhere to grab a quick bite… maybe that’s why My Daddy’s is always pretty busy even though it’s just mediocre pizza.
Nothing really to say about the taste — I’d go back for a quick slice when I’m too lazy to go more than a block away, but wouldn’t recommend it to anyone really. Kinda pricey at $ 2.50 a slice… but crazier is that it becomes $ 3.25 if you add a topping. Slices aren’t huge either.
Place rating: 3
Parker, CO
Meh. Wife was gaga over NYPie. Me well this didn’t raise any flags. Open after midnight.
Place rating: 3
New York, NY
Let me start by saying:
I hate midtown.
I hate the people in midtown.
I hate the cars in midtown.
I hate the smells in midtown.
I hate the food in midtown.
My Daddy’s Pizza is a breath of fresh air in a sea of otherwise shitty air. The food is not awe-​inspiring, but it’s decent pizza and there’s a friendly atmosphere there too.
A bit expensive for pizza in my opinion, but it’s fucking midtown so whatever.
Place rating: 1
Bucks County, PA
I should have known better than to stop at a place called My Daddy’s Pizza, but I had just a few minutes and figured how bad could a slice be?
Pretty bad. The oily glop-​a-​rama ended after 2 bites. An insult at $ 2.50 a slice. I think there was a different place here some time ago that did better slices. Best avoided.