Plum Crazy Pizza

Do not go here! They are rude and disrespectful. Stephanie the girl working the phone is a liar and incompetent. We ordered takeout a
n it never came. When we called asking where it was she said «I don’t know what to tell you?». Doug the manager, if he exists should be aware that his employees are disrespectful and bad at their job.

Friendly staff and good pizza. Also tried the gluten free pizza and it was better than what a lot of other place have for GF. Tried is several times and it was good every time

I just ordered a Calzone and a chicken gyro to be delivered. I was so surprised and delighted with the quality of both. I requested the gyro made «per order» and they happily agreed. it was made with what tasted like homemade pita bread and was huge as was the ingredient packed calzone! This meal inspired me to sign up on Unilocal to write my first review… absolutly delicious!!!

Came up to help an elderly friend and discovered it was the last weekend of bike week is everything was packed. Hoped to grab a quick sandwich for lunch. They had a very small selection to choose from so I ordered a small steak, mushroom and cheese sub and a slice if cheese pizza to eat while waiting. The pizza was mediocre at best, good crust, too much low quality mozzarella and sugary sauce. The steak was something you’d expect from a 7 – 11 microwavable sandwich, smothered with so much cheese the bread started to fall apart. Edible but nothing more.

We just picked up 2 pizzas: a large cheese and small buffalo chicken. Both were burnt on top and the crust was like wet cardboard! How do you burn the top but leave a wet floppy crust? The flavor of the buffalo chicken was awful, my husband had to spit out his first bite.
I placed the order ahead of time and when I picked it up, I asked to add a small garden salad. «Sure no problem» said the guy working the register, handling cash, running his hands through his hair as he goes out back and starts pulling apart a head of lettuce without washing or wearing gloves! I told him I changed my mind and would just take the pizza.
Besides terrible pizza, I wonder how many health violations this place would have if ever inspected. Barf.

We were looking for a quick lunch on our way home to Massachusetts and remembered this place. We had stopped by here once last year to grab a few slices. The place had a much grungier feel than I had remembered. I headed to the bathroom while my husband ordered. On the way to the bathroom you can see into the kitchen and that also looked a little grungy. Then I saw the bathroom. Just yuck. Dried urine on the toilet, hair on the floor, filthy sink that was dry — where are the workers washing their hands? The whole bathroom was just dirty.
I left the bathroom and headed out to the table, which was covered in crumbs and had a few sticky spots. Our food came. We ordered three slices of cheese pizza. All three were a different size and one was burnt.
If you are looking for food while in Meredith, keep driving by this place.

Pulled in after 2 hour drive. So many good choices, so we got a ½ french dip and ½ Plum crazy. Both were delicious! LOADED with fresh ingredients. Lots of shaved steak and yummy caramelized onions. The roasted tomatoes had so much flavor and the bacon was nice and crisp. We got our money’s worth, plus some. We will be back next time we’re in town!

Awesome awesome pizza! Homemade dough, homemade sauce!!! Delicious!!!
Best pizza around!!!

We were spending the day in Meredith and came across this place which looked cute from the outside and did not disappoint inside! This was one of the best pizzas I have ever had! I wish it was close to my home — or maybe not because I’d probably gain 60 pounds being near it!!! But do yourself a favor and try Plum Crazy!!!

Best pizza around, hands down! The gourmet pizzas are incredible, my favorite was the french dip pizza. Service was incredible, and very friendly. The owner offered us some great recommendations and he couldn’t have been more right! Crispy crust and delicious pizza. They even offer delivery or catering which we will definitely be keeping in mind for our next event!