Borderline Bagels

New Milford, United States

2.9

Closed now

14 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 201-599-1990
Address:
440 Madison Ave, New Milford, NJ, 07646
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
0.9 miWashington Avenue at Madison Avenue
0.9 miWashington Avenue at Quackenbush Avenue
1 miRiver Edge
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Accepts Apple Pay
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes

Today

Today 5:00 am – 4:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (New Milford) 12:39 AM Friday, November 29, 2024

Business hours

Monday 5:00 am – 4:00 pm
Tuesday 5:00 am – 4:00 pm
Wednesday 5:00 am – 4:00 pm
Thursday 5:00 am – 4:00 pm
Friday 5:00 am – 4:00 pm
Saturday 5:30 am – 3:00 pm
Sunday 5:30 am – 3:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Old fashion Hand rolled, boiled and baked brooklyn style bagels

Low carb, Rainbow, Flagels, Mini bagels, multi-​grain bagels

protein wraps, Turkey bacon,

Variety of fresh made cream cheeses

Boar’s head sandwiches, special signature wraps

Breakfast specials daily

wings and Fries

Variety of refreshing beverages.

Bubble Tea, Smoothies

History

Established in 1995.

We have been serving Brooklyn style hand rolled bagels over 18 years.

Always use best ingredients for bagels and sandwiches.

phillsbury flours and philladelphia cream cheeses.

Bagel taste has never been changed over the years, and we will continue to serve best bagels in NJ

Related places

You might also like:
1
mi
Minit Mart Food Store
20 Columbia Ave
1
mi
Dumont Hot Bagel
76 Washington Ave
1
mi
Kinderkamack Hot Bagels
935 Kinderkamack Rd
1
mi
New Milford Bagel Express
506 River Rd
1.2
mi
Bergenfield Bakin’ Bagels
55 S Washington Ave
1.2
mi
Bagels and More
54 E Main St

Vicinity

Near this location:
90
ft
Danielle’s Place
438 Madison Avenue
90
ft
Jay’s Car Care
430 Madison Ave
130
ft
Dr N D Bookstaver
440 Madison Ave
180
ft
Nelson Commons LLC
446 Madison Ave
310
ft
Bella’s Maintenance Services
414 Madison Ave
360
ft
Printing Edge
35 Monroe Ave

14 reviews of Borderline Bagels

No registration required
Place rating: 4
New Milford, NJ
I’ve been coming to this bagel shop for years! It’s usually hit or miss. Their bagels are amazing. Always good however their cream cheese can sometimes taste old or not up to par. I get olive cream cheese. My advice would be to go in the morning everything is fresh. The customer service after 2 is horrible. I don’t know his name but he is rude. I have known him to charge more in the afternoon than in the morning.
Place rating: 1
Franklin Lakes, NJ
Look at the Egg Salad or Tuna Salad in the showcase. It has a crusty glaze over it. How can they put this bacterial nightmare on someones sandwich? The Bagels are flavorless and they handle food and money with no gloves. Way too unsanitary for me…
Place rating: 2
Totowa, NJ
Today I go in there and get 3 bagels asking the guy for peanut butter and jelly on bagel and couple of other bagels with cream cheese he goes and puts cream cheese with jelly !!! This place was better before now it’s starting to fall apart, the register Mexican decent person does not know how to take orders or ring up the register. Other younger person that’s always there is polite and fast, this place has to replace employees
Place rating: 2
Montvale, NJ
My boyfriend and I live fairly close to Borderline Bagels and have visited it several times recently. Unfortunately, each time we leave with our order, it is not the exact order we placed. I always just chalk it up to human error, but this is now the second weekend in a row that something was wrong with our order. Today he requested an everything bagel, spicy mustard, ham, lettuce and onions. What I received instead was, the bagel, minus the spicy mustard and adding munster cheese. I realize they are kids behind the counter, but perhaps the owner should pay a little more attention to making sure the staff has an effective system in place considerint this is not the first time.
Place rating: 2
New Milford, NJ
No no no no. Subpar. Quality of bagels is inconsistent. People behind the counter are profoundly inept and navigating getting in and out of here is a nightmare. Waste of time. Go to Dumont Hot Bagels, it’s two blocks away and way better.
Place rating: 1
New Milford, NJ
Unsanitary! Walked out after I saw an employee touch money WITH GLOVES ON and then continue to touch my bagel.
Place rating: 5
Flushing, NY
This place makes their own bagels at the site so the bagels are soft and chewy. My favorite is everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. The bagel is huge and it keeps me full until later in the afternoon. Make sure to try with a freshly brewed cup of coffee. I really really like the taste of it as well. Highly recommended!
Place rating: 5
North Bergen, NJ
I have been regular at this place for some time and hands down the best bagel in the neighborhood. Unlike some bagel stores, they make their own bagels at the store and if you are lucky, you can one just came out of the oven. The bagel size is huge so I usually ask them scoop out in the middle, which is perfect. Employees are nice and friendly too. Highly recommended.
Place rating: 2
Bergen County, NJ
They just screw up so often! Adding ketchup to everything (we’re pretty clear on the «no ketchup» instructions, forgetting bacon, overcharging. it’s just not worth it.
And what kind of bagel place runs out of plain bagels on a Sunday morning?!
Place rating: 5
Bergenfield, NJ
I like to come here. I tried our locations bagels store, but this is the place where I come. The workers are nice and fast, I like the bagels too. My favorite is Sesame and Everything with Cream cheese.
Place rating: 5
Hillsdale, NJ
Still the best bagels around in my humble opinion.
I am there constantly getting bagels and bringing home to freeze and heat up when needed… Keep up the great work Borderline!
Place rating: 1
Paradise, CA
I go here all the time for breakfast and I love it, but today I went for lunch and was so disappointed…:(I asked for the club sandwich on a bagel. They had it written as a lunch special. I got the completely wrong sandwich and it was on a hero. I kept trying to explain to the guy but he just kept saying its the same price. And there was no one else around:(I really don’t want to ever go back, even though I’ve been going for 7 years…:((
Place rating: 2
Dumont, NJ
Bagels here are huge and inconsistent. Too doughy and dense for my liking.
Place rating: 3
Hillsdale, NJ
Boder Line will meet the standards of a Jersey bagel lover like myself, but may not impress the novice Garden State breakfast goer.
In my opinion, the average circumference of the bagels could be larger, but I find the eggs, bacon & cheese between them satisfying enough to keep going back. And I return because they get orders right, serve it fast & sell it for cheap.
The coffee isn’t always my first choice, I drink it on days I haven’t had my caffine yet, which is rare, but happens. (You don’t want to run into me on these days). Anyway, thanks to this store, I can continue to support my bagel breakfast sandwhich eating habit either at one of the small tables they have available inside, or more than likely on the go, out & about.