Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

This was just what I was looking for! The pepperoni pizza was delicious, we also had the white ricotta pizza. The place was packed and we had order to go. Surprisingly they were very fast. You won’t regret it.

Wow that was awesome! That large round pepperoni was the best I’ve had in so long! This was the first time I tried Anthony’s and it is now my new favorite go to pizza! Sauce and cheese reminded me of award winning Buddy’s up in metro Detroit matched with the perfectly baked slightly burned crispy crust. I hope they stay consistent because this pizza was definitely made with heart and pride. Thank you.

This visit was kind of blahhhh.
Always been a favorite of ours, and we were long over due for a visit. The pizza was lacking. Lacking sauce and cheese. And the hostess? Ridiculous and rude. Couldn’t have been more annoyed to step away from her gossip-​fest behind the counter to seat us and other customers.
Come on… get it together.

Our last family dinner in Orlando on June 4, 2016 before we were due to leave. It took a struggle to get there (and later we found out we could have taken a less direct route with much less traffic), but we made it. The place was packed with only 1 table available, but it gradually thinned out while we were there. We were seated right away. Overall, the pizza was very good. We a traditional large, with no other toppings (save that for next time). The crust was a little underwhelming to me for a coal-​fired pizza, but the overall flavor worked, especially with the tomatoes. The basil was more of a hint of flavor, certainly not overpowering. The service was just okay. Our waitress was not that attentive and we had to wait a couple of times for her to show up just to get things like water. But overall the experience was a good one, and now that we know how to find it, we will likely go back the next time we are in Orlando.

The wings and Pizza are awesome if you want thin crust crispy crust and great crispy wings with a lot of flavor and not dried out. Awesome!

Great restaurant amazing pizza! Good prices and service while in town it will be a weekly regular for my boyfriend and I. Love the fresh garlic and raw prosciutto on our pizza

We came expecting pizza. What we got was pizza and excellent customer service. The waitstaff were all really nice and friendly. I highly recommend this place, as not only did they pull off good pizza, but they also pulled off what seemes to be a bit difficult for most places.
If you go, ask for Amanda as your waitperson. She was awesome! :)

Really good Woodford Pizza, great crust and fresh toppings. A very nice place inside with a very nice staff. They have a bar and seating area thst are divided. Really good place for some really good pizza.

Hands down best pizza we’ve had especially from a chain.
Ordered the Paul and Young Ron (meatball italian sausage ricotta and sweet peppers) then added arugula… AMAZING!
Plus built a pruccito onion mushroom and Italian sausage which was equally yummy.

You MUST try the wings!!! I don’t even like wings and these were phenomenal! They are crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside and you don’t need a sauce! I’ve had better pizza at that price, but I cannot get over those wings! To die for!

Food mot fuel. Not usually a funky pizza guy but this one was great! Fresh ingredients and unique combos. I’ll go back!

Best Italian food in Florida. Get the wings, meatballs, and don’t forget a pizza too. They offer a pot filled with 13 meatballs and sauce for $ 29.99. Worth every penny. Third time here and consistently good. Pies are well-​done, so if you don’t like a crispy dark crust, let your waiter know.

Excellent food and service. Was waitress was Amanda and she was outstanding in her service. Went out of her way to accommodate us. Was a really busy night and she kept up with everything and everyone with poise and grace. The pizza, the wings and the Gorgonzola salad was delicious as usual. We had a reservation and they sat us right away. 2^nd time here and never disappointed. Can’t wait to go back!

I first admit that I am a bit of a pizza snob. I do not eat from any of the national chain pizza restaurants. Locally Flippers (flat bread) has been a favorite for me but since they changed their dough about a year ago I have been looking for something better. We arrived on a Friday evening and the restaurant was just starting to fill up. I must say they did a great job of greeting us as soon as we entered and getting us seated. The waitress arrived fairly quickly to our table and we ordered 2 pie’s for dine in.
The décor was nice and sort of a localish sports as would be expected for a pizza joint. I was VERY surprised when our pizzas were delivered in about 8 minutes from placing our order. The sauce was great, not to sweet and not super salty and the crust had that great taste you only get from coal fired. The price was OK not really a bargain but I did not feel like I was taken advantage of either. All in all a solid place for good pizza but not someplace most would want to visit weekly.

I don’t understand why this place gets high ratings. The wings tasted awful (I had better wings from 7-​eleven), pizza was soggy and sour. Never again.

Still on vacation with wifey. Last evening in Orlando. Was literally walking in the door to Flippers to give it a try when wifey said she wasnt feeling it so we ended up at Anthonys.
At first was skeptical as some reviews stated food was burned. Several signs in the seating area said «warning pizza is well done». I thought great, burned thin crust. Freaking awesome.
As it turns out the pizza was fabulous.
The restaurant was loud, and we were seated by the door so everyone waiting for a seat was watching us eat. Like a zoo! They need to put up dome type of divider wall between the door and tables.
Great food. Questionable seating area.

Came in during lunch and spent way too much off the dinner menu! They didn’t even tell me there was a lunch special! Pizza was average,

What is a surefire to make your day at work a bit better? Well, having your boss buy a couple of great pizza definitely helps! As I’ve mentioned in the past, I have a really hard time paying over $ 20 for a pizza, however I may make an exception for this place.
We ordered a large Paul & Young Ron (meatballs, sausage, hot/​sweet peppers & ricotta cheese) along with a Double Pepperoni. Wow. This place absolutely knows how to make a pizza. The pepperoni pizza was very tasty; the grease from the pepperonis, the charred crust and the salty cheese all combined for a great pie. However, the Paul & Young was ridiculous! They weren’t skimpy with the toppings which was great because I was really able to enjoy each bite.
Maybe it’s because I didn’t pay a dime, but this was definitely one of the better pizzas I’ve had in a while. I’ll definitely give them another try.

Super thin pie. Not over sauced and portioned well. Love that «coal fired» crunchy & dirty finish. Split the salad and it was fresh and plenty.

This was my visit here and I was somewhat impressed. I liked how a menu was outside the door before entering and the ladies at the door was kind and welcoming. The atmosphere as mentioned is trendy, sporty, and somewhat loud. They have very dimmed lights in here. I thought the lights were too dimmed to see anything including reading the menu. The server was welcoming and polite. He gave us time to look over the menu and didn’t rush us.
The menu overall: You can get a pizza Small or Large with the original recipe. Each topping is extra from here on. All pizzas are thin crust since it’s coal fried. I thought the prices were a little expensive for charging extra for a topping including just 1 topping. They offer other pizza selections with special toppings. Moving on, salads are available Small or Large. I ordered an Italian salad small for about $ 6. I thought it was not worth the price because it was just a basic salad, nothing fancy. They offer some calzones, but no pasta or anything else similar. They offer some sandwiches though.
I ordered a Large Pizza with Pepperoni and the Italian salad small. My guest & I thought the pizza was great, but wasn’t impressed with it though. I had better tasting pizza in NYC and other places around here.
Overall I think this place was ok and I will not return because it was not my taste of style. I like a large variety menu and something different to my pizza. I wouldn’t suggest or recommend coming here unless you are in the area and want some pizza. The staff was great and pleasing. My experience was not negative, just not impressive. This is just my opinion.