Massey’s Pizza

This is very good pizza from a local restaurant. We ordered two pizzas for takeout which were excellent. A large (14″) Supreme and a large Vegitarian. The pizzas are not inexpensive at nearly $ 20 a pie, but I’d much rather pay a little more for a great pizza than save a few bucks and eat an average pizza. Massey’s is well worth the few extra dollars. Great crust, very good sauce, and lots of toppings. The meats were very good and the veggies fresh.
Highly recommended

I have learned to not expect much when I order pizza at the coast, so Massey’s was a very pleasant surprise. Recently ordered several pizzas while on vacation with the family. Quality and customer service were outstanding. Veggie speciality pizza was outstanding, «world famous» pepperoni was good but really had a bit too much pepperoni on it and overpowered the pie, chorizo fajita pizza had a nice finish and was acceptable.

Salad Bar is fresh and lots to offer. Unlimited trips to the bar too. Pizza has a solid NY style crust, topping are delish. Some of the best Pizza around. No Bull here. Dine in or out back in the open area or take to go.

If I was on death row, Masseys Pizza would absolutely be my last meal. Stuff is terrific. Everything is clean. And they’re playing Led Zeppelin on the radio.

Always polite and friendly, AMAZING deep dish pizza, and yummy, creative speciality pizzas. Highly recommended!

Great pizza and super fast friendly delivery. Pizza was hot and crispy when it got to us and was delicious

This place is great. Pizza is a very thin biscuity crust, so don’t expect NY style… But it is very good nonetheless. The salad bar is excellent, and the lunch buffet is a nice bargain. Restaurant was clean and had nice décor. We were visiting the area for 3 days and ate at least one meal here each day. Can’t wait to come back next year!

So, decided to give this place another try this year. Wrote a low review last year when we visited the area for vacation. Kids were hungry after swimming and wanted pizza. I remembered that the pizza was really good last year (except for the burnt edges). This time, I decided to call ahead and was going to have my food delivered but changed my mind while placing my order and decided to go and pick it up (I wanted to avoid the potential problem of them messing up my order, getting to my condo and then standing there in my doorway looking foolish when I say «you forgot my sauce» as they did last year). I called in and was immediately placed on hold. No biggie, I realize how busy they are based on my experience last year. Within a minute, a male picks up the call. I asked some questions about which subs were popular as they have a large selection on their website. They all looked good on paper but I wanted to know which ones get ordered most often. In a sullen and flat voice, he says «they are all about the same». Ok… I asked the same question about the wings and was given the same, unenthused response. I was told that my order would be ready in about 30 min. I waited 30 minutes before leaving my condo. Upon arrival, there was a short line — no biggie. When I got to the front, a very nice young lady (I didn’t get her name but she was about high school or college age, maybe? Dark hair, beautiful smile) she was very polite and patient given the fact that the phones were ringing off the hook! My order was ready but I did check my order before leaving — it was all correct. I was nervous because, if you read my previous review, they forgot my sauces last year. The young lady even offered to give me some extra sauces which I accepted (ironic, isn’t it?). Now, onto the food. It was really good! My son ordered the meat feast pizza — OMG! Delish! My other son ordered a Stromboli with mushroom and pepperoni — also very good! I ordered a meatball sub — it was so, so. Too much bread and not enough meatballs. It also could have used some more seasoning on it. My hubby ordered the plain and bbq wings. They were pretty standard — nothing special. I would say that if we order from here again (which I plan to do) we will stick to the pizza and Stromboli. The pizza really does have a lot of toppings on it so you get your money’s worth. Speaking of money, their prices are very good — I was impressed given that they are serving a resort area. They don’t seem to be trying to jack the tourists with crazy, high prices. We will order from here again but would recommend to the owners — David and Debbie Trimmer, if they are reading this — have the people who take your phone orders be as enthusiastic as the young lady at the counter. ;-)

There pizza is a little over priced, but because you pay so much, they put hella ton of toppings on there. A large pizza can easily feed three people. I would highly recommend this as an option. This is def better than any chain place.
On a side note, they cut their pizza in a really easy way to share type of style.

Great spot we have made a tradition to hit up on our annual trip to Litchfield. Great pizza and salad bar (your missing out if you get takeout). Had a sub once that was ok, but will stick with pizza (deep dish is great) and salad bar.

Came here on vacation with my family and all 10 of us Italians approved! Great sauce! We loved the subs and pizza. The subs come on delicious rolls and are huge for $ 6! The décor is modern and casual. Seats about 70 people. Salad bar looked great but I didn’t try it.

Pizza was very good. Salad bar was outstanding! If you’re looking for pizza and/​or a salad you can’t go wrong with this place. Only complaint were the small paper cups that they offered for drinks. Why go all out on everything else and skimp on the drinks? Not a big deal and doesn’t take away from the overall very good experience.

Overall it was okay went during happy hour which is between four and eight got a fat tire for $ 2.40 Great price ! Had a very good salad bar clean and good amount of choices. We went there for the pizza though. We got a supreme 14 itch it was beautiful when it came out but when we got to the crust it was chewy and cardboard like. I hated that. The owner even came around and ask how it was not explained that to him. All he said was really? I would love to go back if they could get the crust crispier

Pizza tastes like cardboard. Terrible! I cannot believe they sell this stuff.
They treat their staff badly, from what I witnessed. No wonder they have such high turnover. This obviously correlates with their low reviews that also mention their poor customer service.

Great food, made just as anyone would anticipate amongst a «hole in the wall», pizza joint. Tastes phenomenal and service was just as great. Do not let these other reviews deter you away, this a great place to eat or order food. If you want a higher echelon type service, come up north but I will say these employees are entirely more personable here. They establish an at home feel like everyone knows everybody. So
Truth be told, coming from a northern region this pizza joint is absolutely top on my list. So not let young and inexperienced work force scare you away. Just be patient, relax and they will take care of you just as they did me. WAY BETTER THAN ANY DOMINOS, PIZZA HUT, etc… Authentic and tastes great just try it for yourself.

Exactly like the original in Columbus!!! Best salad bar and our favorite pizza of all time!!! Friendly staff and very clean.
There are lots of other positive reviews for Masseys but are not on the «recommended» list for some reason.

Meh. If you are particular to thin crust pizza, this may be a place for you. We really don’t care for thin and crispy crust on pizza and that appears to be all they serve here. My wife’s personal size 4-​cheese pizza was disgusting. To make matters worse, we added mushrooms to the toppings, they charged us for mushrooms but when we got back to the room, no mushrooms. I had flashbacks to a time when I was willing to eat a cheap frozen pizza as I tried a bite. That one got thrown away. I had the meat pizza. Overcooked crust with burned pepperoni, and just not very good. This is «fast food» pizza, not hand tossed and carefully made. Perhaps the subs are better but I can’t imagine any future where we will ever find out.

Food 5 Stars
Employee management 1 star
We had two personal pizzas and they were excellent
We had two salad bars and were impressed with the selection and quality
We had two beers at a rock bottom $ 2.85 each
We enjoyed NFL games on their large multiple TVs.
But I left enraged and angry.
Why? Glad you asked.
The young lady (Carley) who took our order at the register was friendly and polite. Carley sure put in a solid hour of work during our stay. She took front counter orders. She answered the phone. She cleared tables. She wiped tables. She checked on customers. Carley worked her ass off.
By contrast, we were stunned at the abysmal work ethics of her female co-​worker with the blonde ponytail, who spent the evening flirting with the cooks, flipping her hair, texting on her phone, slowly filling plastic containers with marina sauce as though she was mixing rocket fuel, and licking errant sauce off of her gloveless hands.
It was a shocking display of vanity, cluelessness, immaturity, and a lack of regard and respect for her co-​worker.
I hope the management of Massey’s reads this. I hope they realize what a hard worker they have in Carley. And I hope they realize the rest of the story too.

Great pizza with tons if pepperoni but terrible service on the phone and in person for my carry out order. The crust is nice and crispy and there is a perfect amount of cheese and sauce! I’ve never eaten at the restaurant but the pizza is consistently great every time we get it to-​go on our vacation to Litchfield!

We are here on vacation with a group of friends. After a long day at the beach, we just wanted to order pizza and call it a night. We called this place with about 15 minutes to spare before close. The girl who answered the phone was very nice and accommodating considering the time. We picked up our pizzas and ate them at our hotel. Everyone loved the food. Pizza was thin, cut into squares, and really tasty! Definitely beats calling Dominos.