Nate’s New York Pizza

Best lunch special around. Great New York style pizza and the staff is always super nice.

I love Nate’s! Pizza, Strombolli, and their salad is fresh! And they are connoisseurs of adult beverages that pair nicely with your pizza. This business cares and serves many special needs in the community.

This is the best pizza in the area. Pay attention to the size of the pie you order because they are larger than you think.

So glad you aren’t closed, this is still the most tasty pizza in town. We love it here. Friendly staff and owner is great an greets and interacts with all the customers. Come check it out if you haven’t.

Best pizza in the area. Why are you reading this review?! You SERIOUSLY haven’t been here yet? Do you have no friends? Get to Nates and try their stromboli and pizza immediately! Best deal for the money in all post falls!

I love pizza. Especially NY style pizza. While I’ve had better, Nates is really, really good. We are visiting from Oklahoma but if I lived here, Nate’s would be my place. Really cheesy, quality ingredients and a good sauce and crust.

I was staying in Post Falls due to a power outage in Spokane, and we decided to try Nates. I purchased a Unilocal deal and went in to order my pizza. At first, they were unsure of how to process the deal, but the manager immediately jumped into action and called the owner for clarification. I wasn’t quite sure of what to order, but the employees were wonderful in helping me make my selection. I sat at the bar and enjoyed a cold beverage while I waited for my food to finish cooking.
I ordered the food to go and got it back to our hotel room for my family. The pizza was fantastic. We ordered a half pepperoni and half Idaho spud. It was pretty cool to have potatoes on pizza! The crust was cooked perfectly, the cheese melted to the right consistency and it was obvious that they use fresh ingredients.
We also ordered a small caesar salad, which my wife says was one of the best she has had in terms of freshness.
Overall, this was a great experience, and the staff went above and beyond to accept my Unilocal deal and provide amazing customer service. I will definitely return and recommend this place to friends and family.

Great pizza! Pasta bowl was even super good which is hard to find in a pizza place! Would recommend!

For me I really have to come across a really unique pizza joint to blow me away.
The pizza here is pretty good, I’ve had better NY Pizza but to be fair I didn’t try on their really specialty pizzas. The pricing is upper end of speciality pizza places.
The customer is insanely good, the are super nice and I have a very family friendly appeal.
Def a future customer :)

I would recommend this restaurant to anyone! Amazing pizza, awesome deep fried mushrooms, and great costumer service! Next time we’re in Idaho we will definitely be stopping here for a bite.

You know it is a great pizza when the cheese stretches from the pie to your mouth! Choices of toppings are ones you wouldn’t find in your everyday pizza shop. Unique potato pizza is an Idaho must have. The owner is a community supporter of fundraisers. You have to admire that. I give Nate’s a New York double thumbs up!

Great spot! Pizza was easily in the top five I’ve ever had. Several microbrews on tap, some wine, and I think even liquor. Five seat bar, three TVs, and seating for about 55 others, plus outdoor seating for the nice days.

Always a friendly staff and this guy has a big heart! He’s always helping out the community and does so from deep down where it counts!
My boys love Nates! Huge pizza, tastes great! Fair price. It’s defiantly a must place!

Best pizza East of the Bronx. Good stromboli. OK sandwiches. Go for the pizza. I keep accidentally showing up on Mondays when they are closed because I am so drawn to this place. Slices are double-​size.

The lunch special was a slice of pizza with 2 toppings and a drink. Great value for the price. The surprising thing was the size of the slice. It was huge and was the quantity of a small pizza all on its own. My dining group tried four different slices and all were very tasty.

Awesome pizza! My wife and I ordered a medium pizza and could only eat half of it. Their medium pizza is like a large at most places. You better bring a huge apatite.

Have you ever noticed that Idaho has very appealing business taxes? No, that’s okay. Because you get to share to fruit of it at Nate’s Pizza.
I have always stopped in for the lunch special ($ 5 for almost a square foot of pizza goodness and a refillable soda). Good guy, good place, good pizza!

The cheese bread has a crispy crust and tons of cheese… the dipping marinara sauce is savory vs sweet… YUMMY!!!
The garlic bread is HUGE portion and equally yummy… lots of parm and Italian seasoning…
The pizza here is def worth the visit. my fiancé is from New York and loves this pizza too. I will be a repeat customer!!!
Oh the customer service is amazing!!!

My wife and I were looking for a place in post falls to meet a friend for dinner. Reviews for Nate’s were generally positive, so we decided to give it a try. When we walked in, it seemed like a solid pizza joint. Nothing fancy, but hey — I didn’t come for fancy tables. When you walk up to the counter, you will notice a bunch of huge pizza boxes. The pizza’s get rather large… the small is a big pizza! The largest one (which is like $ 100) is probably big enough to feed 10 hungry people (As a side note: they have a 4 person challenge to eat the giant pizza in 30 minutes. If you win, you get your $ 100 back for the pizza + a prize of like $ 250.00!). Anyway… we spent a few minutes figuring out what we wanted. We decided on some of the garlic breadsticks ($ 6.99) and a medium 18″ Wall Street pizza ($ 25). The breadsticks seemed slightly pricey around $ 7, but the portion is huge — so it’s actually a pretty solid value. The pizza came out 15 – 20 minutes later and was great! The crust was crispy and delicious. The owner, Glen, was great and checked up on us several times.
The pizza’s are expensive, but that’s because they are HUGE! The three of us finished about ½ of the medium pizza, which could probably feed 5 adults. Only only issue was the use of paper plates. While that’s generally what I use at home, it made it difficult to cut the pizza. I ended up cutting through my plate as I cut a piece in half. This is definitely some of the better pizza that I’ve had in the area.
Overall — this was a good a great find and I’m sure I’ll come back!

The pizzas here are mightily big. The 14 inch will easily feed 2 – 3. My wife and I ordered an all meat pizza (the name escapes me now) and it was loaded to the hilt. Lots of cheese as well. The only thing is that I we did not care for the sauce. It was obviously fresh and generously applied but a bit too sweet and garlicy for our taste. This is obviously a personal preference so I would still recommend that you give this place a try. I just dont think for us it will be worth the trip from Spokane again.
I also wanted to mention that the staff was very nice and checked up on us often.