Fehn’s Cake & Cookie Shop

This bakery is pretty good. We go there all the time because they make the best Boston cream donuts and have some delicious cookies. They also make really good challah and pretzels. As far as cake goes they’re ok. But we ordered a custom cake with cream cheese icing and raspberry filling that was surprisingly delicious. Overall this bakery is really good however I do agree that the staff is not always the nicest. They have good and bad days.

The cakes here are so so. I have had good cakes and bad cakes. More bad then good. i don’t think they put the fresh cakes out front. I have gotten several stale cakes. Will not be back here again. There are plenty of other bakeries in the area that are much better.

A good bakery in the area. I’ve been here multiple times, have had cakes and other sweets and all were tasty. Sometimes I come in for baked goods for breakfast on weekends. I don’t see anything wrong with this place. And in fact, one notable thing is they have some of the best Easter chocolate I’ve ever had on Long Island.

I never ordered a big ass cake, but I don’t get how negative the review are here… every once in while I get a craving for some crumb buns, chocolate custard bun or some cinnamon jelly buns… Fehns does a great job. My go to is Modern Bakery in Lindenhurst, but Fehns is a close second and closer to me. I’ve had their Linzer Tarts and Cups, and they were really good too. Not sure why all the haters here, and i presume most of their clientele are older folks who don’t Unilocal a lot. But in any case the Bakery is crowded on Saturday and Sunday morning with people getting their sugar fix… so it can’t be nearly as bad as the reviews to date… at least not in my book…

I ordered a birthday cake the day before I needed it to avoid rushing and waiting. My mom is turning 90. I was told the cake would be ready when I got there. I thought a 12 inch round cake for $ 50 was high but my daughter was also turning 21 so I agreed, it was a special occasion. I was told I was paying $ 4.50 for strawberries to be on the top of cake. whenI got to Fehn’s the cake was not ready. After writing the names on the cake they then realized they didn’t have the strawberries on it that I paid extra for and they proceeded to cut up 2 strawberries and put the pieces on the top. When I asked who the owner was, who I know happened to be behind the counter, she did not come over to talk to me. No one offered any type of customer service or even apologized for being delayed. In today’s day and age, customer service is as important as the quality of the item. There are many terrific bakeries around. I suggest Fehn’s take a look at relations because they just lost a customer.