The Dory in Shelter Island, NY

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:	+1 631-749-4300
Website:	www.doryrestaurant.com
Address:	185 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:	1.2 miGreenport
Categories:	American (Traditional)

Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Today

Today	–
Local time (Shelter Island)	1:00 AM Thursday, June 26, 2025

Business hours

Monday	–
Tuesday	–
Wednesday	–
Thursday	–
Friday	–
Saturday	–
Sunday	–

Related places

Vicinity

Near this location:

200

Marie Eiffel Market

184 N Ferry Rd

210

Piccozzi’s Bike Shop

177 N Ferry Rd

660

US Post Office

6 Grand Ave

740

Stars

17 Grand Ave

740

Sweet Tomato’s

15 Grand Ave

800

The Chequit Inn

23 Grand Ave

4 reviews of The Dory

No registration required

Patrick R.

Place rating: 1
OAKLAND GARDENS, NY

Was here for an event-idiot owner/manager booked for over 100 people when he had only one overworked waitress. Waitress did sensible thing and walked out. Can’t blame her. This place is run by morons. Avoid.
How can they have an event and be so completely and utterly unprepared? In addition to our wedding party, the regulars from the island were coming in and they weren’t being served either.
I place the blame this completely on the owner who does not know to operate a business at all.

Gerald H.

Place rating: 1
Princeton, NJ

Gross.
So since I have to have a minimum amount of words, (gross) I’ll just continue to drag this (gross) review out a bit (gross).
Honestly, it’s a shame this place is so gross. With good food and even somewhat decent service, this (gross) place could be a gold mine. Maybe stop for a beer, but avoid the food… literally all the food… don’t even ask for bread.

Miriam L.

Place rating: 4
Calabash, NC

Great lobster special on Thursday night. Valerie, our server, was the best. We were six had a relaxing dinner on the porch. Valerie also handled a rude, obnoxious diner very professionally. Just in case… the diner was not in our party.

Laura S.

Westchester, NY

Awful food awful service. I ordered the fish and chips and both were very overcooked. I couldn’t finish either as they were so yuk.
The women’s toilets were not in good shape either. Sh** all around the bowl and something disgusting on the walls.

The Dory

Shelter Island, United States