Pie Five Pizza

Best pizza in Stillwater. The reason you can’t call ahead is because it only takes 5 minutes to make your pizza. Since it is buffet style and you go down a line calling ahead makes no sense. You can always get it put into a box and take it home. Again, it literally takes FIVE MINUTES to make.

I got the Athenian pizza, added spinach and mushrooms. I like the ability to add on or take off what you don’t like. We skipped the salad as it didn’t add many more options other than romaine lettuce and it come in a pie crust bowl. The rest rooms were clean and they have a cool automated hand washing sink with dryer. Beverage station is a coca cola self serve which is always good.

Just average. Pizza is okay. Salads aren’t great. The good news is they are quick. I would probably never come here if someone else didn’t want to go so badly. Much better pizza in Stillwater.

Not bad. I come from Athens, GA, the land of Your Pie, so I’m a little biased. The crust here is not as good as Your Pie’s (I think this must be a regional thing, because I dislike thick, dense, buttery pizza crust), but the toppings were great. Unlike Your Pie, where you can get a healthy veggie-​covered pizza for cheap but have to pay a little extra to load up on the fat, this place gives you pretty big portions of cheese and doesn’t charge much for protein.

I like this place OK. I like some of the specialty pizzas they have (forget which ones, though). I think there’s one good one with chicken and kalamata olives and maybe red onions? It’s decent and reliable. A nice addition to a food desert.

All I’m going to say is high quality pizza ingredients, served only in a personal size in a subway sandwich setting where you pick what you’d like and they assemble it In front of you. You can even choose your sauce (red, white, spicy…) and your crust. If you are just feeding yourself, swing by. If you’re needing a whole pizza, this isn’t your kind of place.

Beware — they don’t change their gloves at all. Cheese is mixed with meat is mixed with veggies. If you have any allergies or strong food preferences, this is not the place for you.

Very good and fast pizza. Doesn’t take long to make unlike other similar pizza joints. I got the High Five pizza which is there all meat type pizza. Very good, plenty of meat. The price is what I like the best. $ 6.99 for a pizza or $ 9.99 for a pizza, salad/​desert, drink combo. I wish they had one of these in N OKC. If I ever return I will come here again.

The best fastfood pizza in Stillwater. The only annoying thing is that the queue is always too long at meal time. Sometimes I have to give up eating there.

Fresh. Pizza. Fast.
These are the three words that come to mind when thinking about my pizza from pie five. I ordered the high five which is an all meat pizza and it was awesome! Also I got to add on additional toppings for free! Including chicken and meatballs that do not come on it! I can see myself coming back for seconds!

4 stars for the pizza, 2 stars for the abysmally slow checkout. Good pizza for the price but they need some Industrial Engineering to figure out their process. Everytime I am here my pizza is cold by the time I get it since there is a backlog at the cash register.

So good. I live the gluten free crust– it’s the best one I’ve tried so far.
It’s set up like a Subway sandwich place. They have several pre designed pizzas but you can build your own too. There’s not take out to speak of. All the pies are personal pizza size.
Every thing is really fresh tasting.

The gluten free pizza crust is yummy, more so than typical restaurant gluten free crusts – and the topping choices and flexibility to build your own favorite pizza really wonderful, I love this restaurant!

Solid pizza. Nice options. Thin crust is good without being too filling. Its more expensive for a family than, say, ordering a large pizza and bread sticks from Pizza Hut, for example. I think the ingredients are higher quality at Pie Five than those other chains. I do like that the pizza is ready in 5 minutes. Little Caesar’s is quicker but not as tasty. Overall, this is good pizza if you are willing to pay the premium.

The staff hardly listened to what I wanted on my pizza and I saw a lot of employees not at their station, goofing off, and texting in front of the customers with the same gloves they where handling the food with. Lastly if I (a grown adult) get asked again about if I’m «excited to go home and eat my pizza» I’m not going to be too happy.

Today I went to Pie Five for their pre-​opening. The pizza was free, and all profit made from purchase of sides, drinks, and desserts will be donated to the FCA of Stillwater.
When we walked in, we were instantly greeted by one of the owners. He gave us a rundown of the whole process and told us some information about the owners, which was nice.
Once we got in line, it was a little slow. Similar to Qdoba during the lunch rush. I can’t really complain though, because I kept myself entertained by looking at the giant menu on the wall and imagining all of the possibilities for future pizza feasts.
We eventually got up to bat to prepare our pizza, and here is my only complaint. There was not enough sauce on my pizza. Keep in mind, this was the pre-​opener. There are still some things to work on, and honestly, in the grand scheme of things, amount of sauce isn’t very important. He was very clearly still learning how to do his job, which is fine.
After the sauce (Alfredo), I loaded it up with ricotta, spinach, and their mozzarella/​provolone blend. I was disappointed that they didn’t have feta available at the time, but that isn’t a make-​or-​break detail. The girl who added all my toppings popped the pizza in the oven and I moved on to my salad.
The salad comes in a pizza crust bowl, which is a very interesting idea. It cuts down on costs because they don’t have to use actual bowls or containers. Personally, I didn’t like it. It was like a saltine cracker, which I just don’t like. My boyfriend loved it though. They have all kinds of things that you can put on your salad, and five different dressings to choose from. While they make your salad, you can choose a dessert if you want. I didn’t get one this time around, but I will say that both the caramel brownie and the chocolate chip cookie pizzas looked delicious.
After the salad/​dessert, you move onto the register, where your finished pizza and sides are waiting for you. Once you pay, if you get a drink, you move onto the freaking awesome soda fountain. It’s one of those electronic ones that has the touch screen and all sorts of different flavors. Can you tell that I loved it?
Onto the pizza. Overall, it was good. The crust was amazing. Sauce was lacking in flavor, but it’s sometimes hard to find a good alfredo. Toppings were amazing. No complaints there! The salad was great too, aside from the bowl.
The price is amazing. $ 9.99 for pizza, salad, and drink. Just a pizza is $ 6.99, with as many toppings as you want. A kid’s pizza is $ 2.99 if I remember correctly. All in all, Pie Five gets 5 stars. Hope you choose to try it when it opens!