The Fat Tomato Pizza and Grill

My favorite place ever. Never had a bad dish. Love their burgers and 4 cheese pizza. They even sometimes do off menu items if you want to change it up. Diamond in the rough

Probably one of my favorite places food is always great and family owned come here several times a month awesome!

Never will I order chicken Marsala from here again. I’ll say that much. $ 20 on a plate that I had to season my self?! Seriously, the least they could have done was use a little salt. This dish was awful and I’m extremely frustrated about it. Maybe it’s because they were soon to be closing? I don’t know. Whatever the case I don’t know if I’ll ever eat here again but if I do I will NOT order a $ 20 season-​less chicken Marsala.

Best Italian food I had. Great service and delivery. Everything I had is great and can not get it anywhere else.

Absolutely love this place. The pizza is great and so are the steaks. The family that owns it are extremely nice everytime I go there. Always have a smile on their face. Very nice inside. Might cost a tad more then other places but its worth it.

Very disappointed with the customer service with this establishment. After receiving our food an 1:45 minutes after ordering on a weeknight, we had come to find all of our food was completely cold, and the fries were over cooked to the point they were inedible. After calling to hopefully resolve this issue I had spoken with the owner and he denies that his kitchen could produce any food to the quality that I spoke of. Not offering any resolution and frankly being quite rude about the whole situation. I have been a customer since this place has opened and it really puts a bad taste in my mouth. All in all I will definitely not be returning due to the lack of customer service and the cold chicken cutlets…

Every dish was fresh tasting. The tomato and white bean soup, penne and meatballs with flavorful tomato sauce as well as the pizza was delicious. The wait staff was prompt and accommodating. A cozy atmosphere with nice décor and pleasant music.

I had been a regular customer for years. even brought in several friends to family to the restaurant.
Don’t try to book the back room. They require a $ 50 deposit and are very rude about it.
Didn’t have to treat me as such.
Lost my business. and I will share this with my friends.

Service lousy
Food good
Atmosphere loud
Seating lousy
Value not to good
Presentation good

I absolutely love this place. From the appetizer to the home made chocolate cake. You can never go wrong. The service is always great. Don’t get just pizza! Don’t get me wrong pizza is great, but the salmon is fresh & amazing. One of the best BYOB Italian rest restaurants around. A must eat!

The reason for my giving this establishment only 3 stars is because the service was absolutely lousy. There is no reason that my two year old should have waited a half hour for his dinner. Our waitress was lifeless and it was not until I looked physically annoyed that she became friendly. We were told that our food was going to be a while because they needed to cater to a larger party. So because there is a larger party the rest of us need to suffer? The food was fresh and delicious but I’m not sure I would rush back due to the terrible service. Such a shame.

I needed to update my original review and unfortunately not for the better after last night’s dinner at Fat Tomato. The two stars merely represent 3 things: their fries, buffalo sauce, and eggplant parmigiana. And I’m stretching it.
My family and I were extremely disappointed by the service at Fat Tomato last night. When our waitress came over to take our order after we needed another minute to decide, she actually just came over and stood at the table. Not a word was spoken. So I took the lead and ordered the calamari zinger for an appetizer, Voorhees sandwich for myself (described as thin roast beef, red onion, horseradish, and swiss), the tomato pie for my husband, and a $ 9.50 boneless buffalo chicken kids meal that doesn’t include a drink. I’ve mentioned my annoyance with this in my previous review but my daughter loves their buffalo sauce so much that I order it for her because she gobbles it up.
The calamari zinger was good, not the best calamari but not the worst. My roast beef sandwich was inedible. The kaiser roll was so wet and soggy it was falling apart as I was attempting to eat it. I understand that this happens with a hot roast beef sandwich but usually it’s because of the au jus not because of too much horseradish sauce. The actual roast beef tasted worse than the Steak-​Ums from the frozen food section that my mom made in be 90’s. Very dry and stringy. I had about three bites.
If our server came over to our table one time to ask how our food was or if we needed anything, I could have told her about my sandwich. I actually witnessed her asking a table 10 feet from us several times if they were okay. The only time we saw her was when she asked if I wanted a box and I explained to her how I could not eat my sandwich. She said sorry and took my plate away. When we got the check my sandwich was still on there, which is fine. I never expect a restaurant to take my meal off the check but maybe offer us dessert or a half price app for next visit? How about have the manager come see if everything is okay? Not only was it not off the check but she didn’t even thank us or say a simple «have a nice night». She placed the check on our table and walked away. My husband went to the register to pay and spoke to the manager. He said, «Oh, sorry. I’ll have to check the meat». That’s it.
Not sure why Fat Tomato decided that they did not want to show us any hospitality last night. We were very polite, my daughter was well behaved, and we did not cause a problem whatsoever about my horrible sandwich.
When we first found this place a few months ago, we were excited to find a new spot for some good food. Every single time we’ve come afterwards, which has been about 3 – 4 times, it’s gotten worse in terms of customer service and quality of food.

We have passed this restaurant a million times on Route 73 but never stopped in. Well we finally did and were pleased.
It’s a small establishment but cozy and smelled wonderful.
It was a busy, crowded Friday night but we snagged a table for 3.
Our server told us the specials and we ordered.
Me: grilled chicken Ceasar salad
Wife: chicken Cavatelli in a vodka sauce (special)
Mother in law: chicken and eggplant parmigiana
Food was good! Served hot and everything tasted fresh.
We will return.

Loved it a jem tucked away in strip center in Berlin. All I can say go there. Our hostess helped us with menu but anything we ordered would of been very good. I watched what others ordered and the presentation was beautiful. I wanted to try it for a long time but my hubby was resistant because he said he wanted to be sure he would get a good meal. We were blown away.

Food was okay, not the best nor the worst I’ve had. If it wasn’t for the waitress that was serving 9 tables all by herself or the two cooks that were making everything fast and with a nice presentation I wouldn’t give this place a 4.

Excellent food and ambience wholly unexpected in a nondescript strip mall. Delicious!

Very good Margherita pie, stopped in late nite & were not disappointed! Fresh Basil, crispy crust, excellent sauce– not too salty– perfecto! We’ll definitely be coming again soon!!!

Great place when we want pizza but good quality, not greasy and flat. As others mentioned, it’s in a weird plaza but really nice inside. We ate in some time ago and the eggplant rollatini is still memorable. It’s a convenient place for us to meet friends for lunch (berlin, rt 73) instead of a fast food place/​chain restaurant. Better service and awesome food here!

Love this little place in the middle of nowhere. We started with the Calamari Zinger and unlimited homemade fresh ice tea. I went with the Margarita Pizza with extra meatballs. Girlfriend went with Arugula Pie and mother-​in-​law went with Bruschetta Pie. Their pizza is good, really good. If you ever in the neighborhood of South Jersey & No-man’s land, try Fat Tomato. True Italian food, great service, and very clean.

So I came to this place based off of Unilocal reviews and I was pleasantly surprised… I ordered a Caesar salad and cheese garlic bread. The service was friendly and quick. and the food was really good. The salad was very fresh…