The Top 20 Bagels in Staten Island, NY

Fresh reviews:

Very small place, you have to make your own cup of coffee, you order then wait by the register for an older woman to ring you up, bagels were just okay… too soft, nothing special.

Casey R.

The Bagel Bin

I have been given bagels with almost NO cream cheese here so many times, it is really a «shame on me» situation considering I kept going here. The old guy will give you a dry bagel every time. Today was the final straw. My husband stopped here and brought home bagels that had so little cream cheese that i took…

Dee G.

Bagels & Buns

The employees are rude. the food is spoiled and I sick from the tuna fish. It made me throw up all weekend and the employees are nasty and I had to repeat myself 5 times for the person what my order was. She looked like I had 5 heads. She was very worried about other things that everyone else was doing and…

Emily N.

Manor Bagels & Superette

Just moved to Staten Island from Brooklyn where I was spoiled with some pretty awesome bagel spots near my house but now I’m searching for my new regular spot and this place is definitely not it.Aside from rude people working behind the counter that are just defensive all the time, probably because they are so…

Rob G.

Bagels R Us

If I could give zero stars I most definitely would. I ordered at 10:00 am my delivery did not show up until 12:00 WORST PLACE EVER NOT WORTH THE WAIT AT ALL FOOD EAS COLD!!! Two hours for this I will never be ordering from here again !!!

Ashley S.

Bagel Bistro Diner & Grill

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Annadale

Arden Heights

Arrochar

Castleton Corners

Dongan Hills

Eltingville

Graniteville

Grant City

Grasmere

Great Kills

Heartland Village

New Dorp

Oakwood

Old Town

Princes Bay

Richmond Town

Rossville

St. George

Sunnyside

Tottenville

West Brighton

Westerleigh

47 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

Hot Bagels & More

5.0

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-967-1144
Address:	758 Arthur Kill Rd

Bagels /

Bagels & Buns

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-761-1900
Address:	2491 Victory Blvd

Bagels / Bakeries / Coffee & Tea

Heartland Bagels II

3.9

17 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-966-8494
Address:	1024 Rossville Ave

Bagels /

Bagel Depot Richmondtown

3.9

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-987-7682
Address:	3459 Richmond Rd

Bagels /

Heartland Bagels

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-761-4289
Address:	2311 Richmond Ave

Bakeries / Bagels

Mikey Bagels

4.0

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-984-9700
Address:	7420 Amboy Rd

Bagels /

Bagel Mercato

3.9

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-442-7900
Address:	70 Bay St

Bagels / Breakfast & Brunch

Bagel Land

3.8

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-273-1963
Address:	1841 Forest Ave

Bagels /

East Shore Bagel

4.2

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-442-4106
Address:	170 McClean Ave

Bagels /

Bagel Depot

3.5

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-948-8755
Address:	3854 Richmond Ave

Bagels /

Country Donuts & Bagels

3.4

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-967-7111
Address:	3235 Richmond Ave

Bagels / Donuts

Bagel House

3.3

13 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-227-0503
Address:	4651 Hylan Blvd

Bagels /

Bagels By The Bay

3.4

17 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-815-4447
Address:	1235 Bay St

Bagels / Breakfast & Brunch

Hillside Gourmet

3.3

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-673-2169
Address:	1664 Richmond Rd

Bakeries / Bagels

Manor Bagels & Superette

3.1

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-370-1292
Address:	931 Manor Rd

Bagels / Delis

Au Bon Pain

3.2

18 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-420-0846
Address:	Staten Island Ferry Terminal 1 Bay St

Coffee & Tea / Bagels / Sandwiches

Forest Avenue Bagels

3.2

10 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-720-5827
Address:	1180 Forest Ave

Bagels /

Not Just Bagels

2.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-351-8870
Address:	1910 Hylan Blvd

Bagels / Delis / Cafes

The Bagel Bin

2.9

12 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-442-2300
Address:	486 Forest Ave

Bagels /

Bagel Bistro Diner & Grill

2.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-720-6919
Address:	1810 Victory Blvd

Bakeries / Bagels / American (New)

Linden

Kearny

Elizabeth

The Top 20 Bagels

Staten Island, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

Staten Island Neighborhoods

47 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

Bagels in nearby cities: