The Top 20 American (New) in Staten Island, NY

Fresh reviews:

In my book Basilio Inn is Hands Down The BEST Italian restaurant on Staten Island!I have eaten at all of the islands staples that everyone has recommended to me over the years, and around 25 or so other places that I’ve tried on the island. There are a hand full that are memorable the rest you might as well go…

Vincent S.

Basilio Inn

So I can’t speak of the food, but I jumped on Unilocal and found a restaurant near by that took reservations. We arrived on time and walked into a completely empty restaurant that had a waitress watching TMZ. She said sit wherever you’d like and we literally had all ten tables that are in this place to…

Sharleen G.

Paradise Restaurant

NEVER plan a party here! Total ripoff. Never go back again.

William K.

Manor Restaurant

This place is way overpriced. I ordered a large milkshake for $ 8 and it was watered down. The steak sandwich was decent for $ 9 but you have to order a minimum of $ 20 which is outrageous. I gave the delivery driver a $ 4 tip because he was fast but other than that this place is a big waste. I called the owner…

Matt G.

Lunchbox

My first time here as I’m not from Staten Island. Place wasn’t bad… not my scene or my type of ppl. Guess it’s cool if ur from SI.Sat @ outside bar which was cool. Drunk guy to our left played guitar for us (shoulda been cut off long ago).My girlfriend asked for a ketel club. Few minutes go by & my friend…

Maria V.

South Fin Grill

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Annadale

Arden Heights

Arrochar

Castleton Corners

Charleston

Dongan Hills

Elm Park

Eltingville

Graniteville

Grant City

Great Kills

Heartland Village

Old Town

Rossville

Shore Acres

Silver Lake

Stapleton

Sunnyside

Tompkinsville

West Brighton

Westerleigh

53 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

Basilio Inn

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-720-6835
Address:	6 Galesville Ct

Italian / American (New)

Gatsby’s On The Bay

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-442-8729
Address:	695 Bay St

American (New) /

Against Da Grill

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-442-3433
Address:	60 Van Duzer St

American (New) /

How Greek It Is

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-273-3200
Address:	2224 Hylan Blvd

Greek / American (New)

Paradise Restaurant

3.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-967-9333
Address:	1281 Arthur Kill Rd

American (New) / Seafood / Steakhouses

Vida

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-720-1501
Address:	381 Van Duzer St

American (New) /

Joyce’s Tavern

3.9

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-948-0220
Address:	3823 Richmond Ave

American (New) / Burgers / Irish Pub

Alor Cafe

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-351-1101
Address:	2110 Richmond Rd

American (New) / Breakfast & Brunch / Lounges

Li Greci’s Staaten

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-448-6000
Address:	697 Forest Ave

American (New) / Caterers

Joe Broadway’s Billiards & Sports Pub

3.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-727-9194
Address:	2178 Forest Ave

Pool Halls / Bars / American (New)

Gyro King

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-524-7875
Address:	1267 Forest Ave

American (New) / Halal

Manor Restaurant

3.8

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-698-4433
Address:	917 Manor Rd

American (New) /

Muscle Maker Grill

4.1

17 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-984-7455
Address:	4916 Arthur Kill Rd

American (New) /

Lunchbox

3.2

26 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-448-2929
Address:	1612 Forest Ave

American (New) / Sandwiches / Salad

Play Sports Bar

3.4

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 347-815-1343
Address:	2 Sneden Ave

Sports Bars / American (New)

PepperJack Grill

3.8

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-816-6466
Address:	316 Manor Rd

American (New) / Art Galleries / Music Venues

Miller’s Ale House - Staten Island

3.4

30 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-477-0112
Address:	2883 Richmond Ave

Seafood / American (Traditional) / Sports Bars / American (New)

Sunnyside

Long Island City

Manhattan

The Top 20 American (New)

Staten Island, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

Staten Island Neighborhoods

53 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

American (New) in nearby cities: