The Top 20 Sandwiches in Staten Island, NY

Fresh reviews:

Everything we’ve had here was fresh and delicious. Lots of veggies on the menu and healthy options but still delicious.

Me M.

I would give 4 stars except for I can’t use card here ;P the customer service was so great. And the food was delicious I was not disappointed what so ever. I don’t spend a lot of time in SI but when I went there the last time I had to try DeFonte’s out. I’m glad I had some cash on me.

Blaire H.

DeFonte’s

Again a bagel store that doesn’t make coffee for you, they do have parking, people were very nice, bagel was okay, nothing compared to Brooklyn. Then I found a hair in my bagel, which made me disgusted… I’m determined to find the perfect bagel… some how, some way…

Casey R.

Milk N-Things

This place has amazing sandwiches and most of the staff is great.I would have def given them a 5 star except for the horrible middle aged woman with glasses who works behind the counter.She is nasty and rude over the phone for no reason whatsoever. She has the worst attitude and is short with every response…

Bruno S.

Artisan Bakers Group

This place is way overpriced. I ordered a large milkshake for $ 8 and it was watered down. The steak sandwich was decent for $ 9 but you have to order a minimum of $ 20 which is outrageous. I gave the delivery driver a $ 4 tip because he was fast but other than that this place is a big waste. I called the owner…

Matt G.

Lunchbox

A 20 minute wait for you to re-stock the ONE breakfast item on your menu? At 9:30 on a Saturday morning? Really? Poor planning or poor management? I’m not sure, since you had a full staff — I counted at least 4 or 5.

Neil S.

Panera Bread

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Annadale

Arrochar

Bullshead

Charleston

Chelsea

Clifton

Concord

Dongan Hills

Elm Park

Eltingville

Graniteville

Grant City

Grasmere

Great Kills

Heartland Village

Mariner

Midland Beach

New Brighton

New Dorp

New Dorp Beach

Oakwood

Old Town

Park Hill

Port Richmond

Rosebank

Shore Acres

St. George

Stapleton

Tompkinsville

Tottenville

West Brighton

Westerleigh

98 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

Leo’s Deli Sandwich Shop

5.0

16 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-815-8757
Address:	1153 Forest Ave

Delis / Sandwiches / Salad

John’s Famous Deli

4.8

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-815-9100
Address:	15 Innis St

Delis / Breakfast & Brunch / Sandwiches

DeFonte’s

4.7

26 reviews

Telephone:	+1 929-267-4381
Address:	95 Water St

Italian / Sandwiches

Dazzle Gourmet Bagels & Deli

4.3

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-967-8977
Address:	3295 Richmond Avenue

Delis / Sandwiches

Call It A Wrap

4.4

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-876-8300
Address:	1198 Forest Ave

Health Markets / Sandwiches / Vegetarian

Artisan Bakers Group

4.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-605-0122
Address:	708 Sharrotts Rd

Sandwiches / Bakeries

Jimmy John’s

4.1

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-980-0071
Address:	1919 Hylan Blvd Ste 1

Sandwiches /

The West Shore Inn

4.4

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-698-9722
Address:	3955 Victory Blvd

Steakhouses / Seafood / Sandwiches

Lunchbox

3.2

26 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-448-2929
Address:	1612 Forest Ave

American (New) / Sandwiches / Salad

Page Plaza Diner

3.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-966-3500
Address:	75 Page Ave

American (Traditional) / Diners / Sandwiches

M & M Deli & Bagels

3.7

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-966-6826
Address:	849 Annadale Rd

Bagels / Delis / Sandwiches

Panera Bread

3.4

16 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-966-0304
Address:	2965 Veterans Road West

Sandwiches / Salad / Soup

Panera Bread

3.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-494-2450
Address:	280 Marsh Avenue

Sandwiches / Salad / Soup

Au Bon Pain

3.2

18 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-420-0846
Address:	Staten Island Ferry Terminal 1 Bay St

Coffee & Tea / Bagels / Sandwiches

Mangia Healthy Kitchen

2.9

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-356-4400
Address:	20 Jefferson Blvd

Juice Bars & Smoothies / Gluten-Free / Sandwiches

Pronto Pizza

2.9

14 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-448-1166
Address:	738 Forest Ave

Pizza / Italian / Sandwiches

Justino’s Pizzeria

2.5

17 reviews

Telephone:	+1 718-668-2020
Address:	89 Guyon Ave

Pizza / Italian / Sandwiches

Union City

Long Island City

Piscataway

The Top 20 Sandwiches

Staten Island, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

Staten Island Neighborhoods

98 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

Sandwiches in nearby cities: