Wise Guys Pizza

Just went to get my monthly Wise Guys fix and there was a letter on the door saying they closed for good effective April 25^th. Say it ain’t so! This is no bueno! Honestly don’t think there is a suitable replacement in Fishers where every shop spouting up is trying to get all artsy fartsy with «specialty» pies. Give me great crust and ooey, gooey cheese with quality toppings.

This is the only pizza I’ve ever had that doesn’t make me feel terrible! It’s not greasy at all, no nasty dripping. The Hawaiian BBQ Chicken is excellent. Bread sticks are a carb lovers dream, huge and dense. BBQ Chicken Chop Salad is tasty, the lunch portion is huge. Great lunch specials throughout the week. Delivery takes a bit longer, 45 – 60 minutes, but it’s worth the wait. They just added pretzel bites not too long ago, love them! Delicious food, one of my favorite spots in Fishers.

This has been a pizza staple for me. I had the spicy Italian Stromboli with mini stix for lunch and it was awesome. best bread sticks and sauce around

Great place for pizza. Highly recommended the cini-​minies. They are incredible. Very friendly service.

I’d put this on my top 5 local pizza places (and we eat a lot of pizza!). Prob not someplace I’d dine in, but great for carry-​out or delivery. Breadsticks were good– would have been «amazing» if they weren’t just a tad over cooked. Still great taste, just made them a little tougher than they needed to be. Pepperoni/​onion pizza was good– tons of cheese. Love the sauce/​cheese/​toppings. The crust could have had just a little more flavor for my liking. Caprese salad was also nice– more of an Italian/​balsamic dressing instead of a straight balsamic. Will def return.

We have eaten at this restaurant on two occasions. The inside of the restaurant is no-​frills, but we were satisfied with the food and service. The breadsticks were excellent and we liked that they came with two sauces. The pizza was good with the right amount of Italian seasoning. We enjoyed the pizza that have 5 different meats on it. It wasn’t the best pizza in the world, but it was satisfying and they don’t skimp on toppings. I would return.
I would give this restaurant a 3.5 overall.

Stopped in for their lunch special: Stromboli, Breadsticks, and a drink for $ 10. Now, I’ve been on a real pizza kick these last couple of weeks, and I regret to report, I was underwhelmed by Wise Guys.
First things first, I felt very awkward ordering… almost like I was bothering the person at the front counter… I’d never been here before, and since I love to eat local, I was excited to try! I was just asking questions about the menu when a woman came up from the back and began speaking OVER me to the customers behind me. wait…what!!!
Alas, I continue ordering and after I get my total and wait for what I was hoping to be a knock my pants off stromboli, I get back to my desk at work to begin my meal… and I take a nice big honkin bite into a cold stromboli… oh man. Now, I just ate around the middle (which was the cold part) and that wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t great either. I want to go back and try just getting slices next time, but hopefully in the future the service staff won’t look at me like I have four heads and a dog flying out of my ear…

Need to update Google search results to indicate closed on Sunday.
Great pizza though!

I ventured out this evening in search of a new dining experience. This was partly motivated by the desire for something new, but it was also motivated by my growing addiction to Unilocal.So, I decided to head up Allisonville Road in search of something new or, at the very least, something I’d never really viewed through a critical lens. As I was driving into Fishers, I had to chuckle as I experienced multiple pizza joints in a row. While a couple of them looked newer and shinier, something drew me to Wise Guys Pizza, a rather basic hole-​in-​the-​wall pizza joint with a fairly modest sign in a fairly modest strip retail center.
Pizza joints can be a real hit and miss option for a single guy who frequently dines alone. I never know for sure if a place is going to have a decent meal option for a single person. By decent, I mean both price and portion size is appropriate for one person.
I will say that it became readily apparent I’d have been better off if I’d have arrived in time for one of their lunch specials. The «regular» prices are definitely a tad higher than I’d planned on paying, but fortunately they do take credit cards so I was good to go. The lunch specials go until 2pm, but they do serve personal size pizzas throughout the day.
I ordered one of their special concoctions called the «Meaty,» an 8″ (personal size) beast of a pizza with, if I remember correctly, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and I think one more topping. It also included 3 of their mini breadsticks. For the record, I’d consider their «mini» breadsticks to be more generous than quite a few regular breadsticks. I added an iced tea to the mix. The pizza and breadsticks deal was $ 10.00, while the drink adds another $ 1.99. My total bill was $ 12.95, which isn’t unreasonable but definitely borders on «average» in terms of value. In addition to lunch specials, they also have a daily special.
However, it can’t be stressed enough that the pizza is absolutely top notch. The 8″ pizza with breadsticks filled me up and, quite honestly, I probably should have stopped before it was gone. They have thin, hand-​tossed, pan (which costs just a bit extra), and all their stuff is made from scratch. Their entire kitchen is visible within the restaurant, so you can actually sit there and watch your pizza being made. The crust was nearly perfect with a nice crispness, brown edges, but never burnt. The toppings were generous and the entire pie was simply quite enjoyable. The breadsticks, which everyone seems to rave out, are definitely worth raving about.
Because I went in during an off-​time, probably about 45 minutes or so before the earliest dinner hour, the small establishment was empty. The two employees working, including the owner I believe, were incredibly friendly and helpful. While the place was small enough that I was concerned my wheelchair could be an obstacle should the crowd start to show up, their layout is good enough that they have a couple of decent options for wheelchairs.
They also do have a loyalty card and you earn 1 punch (I had to laugh at the idea of getting a «punch» at Wise Guys) for every $ 10 spent. When you get 12 punches, you get a large 1-​topping pizza free. I find that remarkably generous.
Shortly before I finished, their delivery help for the evening arrived and they were equally friendly and helpful. Customers were starting to arrive as I was finishing up, though it seemed the majority of their business was delivery, carry-​out, and catering but they definitely do have a dining area. As I noted, this is a bit of a hole-​in-​the-​wall. This means the restaurant itself doesn’t have that spic-​n-​span feeling and certainly isn’t brand new, but they’d clearly made an attempt to go with the wise guys theme and had some of the more famous «wise guy» movie posters decorating the place.
I’m not sure that I see Wise Guys Pizza becoming a regular stop, but it was definitely a quality meal with great customer service at a fairly decent price. If I’m in the neighborhood, there’s no question it would be a prime dining option. It is worth noting for those in wheelchairs that the strip center’s wheelchair ramps aren’t up to ADA code and I did have to work a little bit harder to maneuver the ramp.

They have the best bread sticks and nacho cheese sauce. Their Pizza, calzones, salads are always fabulous. Love the antipasta salad! We don’t live that far, but I’d come from far away to eat here. The service is great, they have very friendly staff. We like the daily specials, too.

Fantastic, food with generous portions and great owners in Jon & Beth! My group tried about everything on the menu it seemed and absolutely loved everything. We had various types of pizza including glueten free, pretzels, chicken wings, and parmesan & cinnimmon bread stixs. Our group would definitely recommend this family run pizzeria!

Did you know there are about 25 «specialty» pizza places in the Carmel/​Fishers area? I cannot imagine trying to compete in that market! Lucky for Wise Guys, they have hand tossed homemade Parmesan breadsticks that come with — wait for it — at least two sauces and up to four for the large order! You get to mix and match. I love that it isn’t «extra» for more sauce (especially since my two toddlers cannot share one dipping bowl).
Tonight I got delivered the blackened chicken Alfredo with an extra side of Alfredo and my hubby and kiddos shared a medium supreme. The pizza was slightly greasy coming out box but my kids looooved it. Hubby devoured all but one piece. The Alfredo was a good balance and although it was blackened there was no real «kick» to it which is fine by me.
Everyone we dealt with was very friendly. However it was kind of a long process to order. He couldn’t seem to hear me at all and was perhaps distracted. They were very busy! But the order was right and he warned it would be an hour or so and it was right at an hour. Not really any different than most places on Friday night.
Tip: they do a daily special which they tell you about on the phone when you call. It seemed great for tonight but we passed after perusing the menu.
I will be trying the oven baked chicken wings. They sound amazing and if they are as fresh to order as the food we had tonight I have a feeling it’s going to be incredible. I love me some wings.

The food is excellent! They have everything from pizza, pasta, and calzones, to salads. And everything is great. The prices are reasonable, especially the prices on the lunch specials. I’ve had the pepperoni pizza and the lasagna. Everything tastes really fresh; the crust is definitely handmade. We order from Wiseguy’s at my job quite a bit. I’ve never actually been to the location to eat so I can’t say what the dine-​in experience is like. One drawback, the delivery guys are some of the most socially-​awkward on record, like seriously uncomfortable to interact with, but once you get your food you forget about it and all is well.

So delicious, and their lunch specials are excellent! $ 7 for a 2 topping personal pizza, 3 bullets (little breadsticks) and a drink. If you’re extra hungry, it’s plenty of food to satisfy. If not, you could easily get 2 meals out of this! My friend from work got the $ 7 stromboli and a drink lunch special and the stromboli was HUGE! Definitely recommend Wise Guys to anyone that loves a good pizza!

Great local restaurant and love the breadsticks with cheese sauce. Good value too!

I’ve had the pizza lunch a few times and it’s really good. It’s also a bargain — under $ 5 for a two, one-​topping slices; three garlic knots; and a drink. I seem to be on a black olive kick and they are very generous with the olives when I order.

My wife and I were looking to try a new pizza place on a cold and snowy day. After perusing the reviews on Unilocal!we decided on Wise Guy’s. We were not disappointed.
It was a really hard to decide what we were going to get. The size of the menu is extensive with many different combo’s and specialty pizzas. We decided on the medium pie and breadstick combo (a great value by the way). The breadsticks were fantastic. You could tell that they were made to order. They were MASSIVE and steaming hot with a nice crispy crust and soft doughy center. Honestly the best sticks I have EVER had. We ordered the pizza with peperoni, sausage and mushrooms. The crust was the best part. Crisp yet moist and tender as well.
We were also impressed withe the service. This is a very small space and we weren’t quite sure what to do when we came in. Do we order at the counter or grab a seat? The staff was very friendly and told us to have a seat and took our order. They were very attentive and frequently checked to see if we needed a refill on our drinks.
Overall I was very satisfied with the meal and service we received. I will make it a point to go back. I really want to try the Greek Pizza.

Best pizza in Fishers, hands down!
The owner is always there working so you know he is making sure things are good, the staff is friendly and fun and the pizza is DELICIOUS!!!
If you haven’t been to Wise Guys yet, you are missing out! Fresh made quality is always worth trying out!

Just order from here, literally eating my calzone as I type. DELICIOUS!!! I had my doubts after reading the review on here, but its the only place around my office that delivers, and its just getting too cold out to let my car warm up and go get something. Being able to find a mom and pop place that is this good still manages to blow me away in Indy!!!
A co-​worker ordered a Chicken Cesar salad and commented about how garlicky it was, which to me translates to a good Chicken Cesar. My boss is thoroughly enjoying his Roma Hand tossed pizza, I also finished off the light fluffy garlic, parmesan breadsticks that had come with the salad. They were soft thick and well coated. My calzone is HUGE, roughly a med pizza folded in half and over stuffed with cheese, pepperoni, bacon, and a sweet, spicy pizza sauce… MMMMMMMM!
The food deserves 4 stars, but the staff, both the guy that took the order and the delivery driver really earned them the 5^th!
OH and be aware– the website has changed:
is were you can now find the FULL menu!

I’m a big supporter of hole in the wall/​mom and pop joints, but this place wasn’t really doing much for me.
I was craving some pizza the other day, and I saw this place recommended by yahoo (mistake, should have stuck with Unilocal). There are a number of other pizza joints that I have bookmarked to try, but this place was fairly close, so I figured why not (again, mistake).
Looked up their menu online– they have a number of specialty pizzas in addition to sandwiches, calzones, and breadsticks. My wife and I tried their bbq chicken pizza and breadsticks deal. The pan pizza wasn’t that thick, and the chicken was shredded as opposed to most places that dice it. It was good not great. Their breadsticks were covered with parmesean cheese and butter. They came with garlic and marinara dipping sauces. Again, good not great. As far as reheating the food, it certainly seemed to have lost a step (as most places do).
Overall, I can’t say that we were that impressed. There are places that are closer to us, that are probably comparable. They may be worth another look for their calzones, but I’m not holding my breath.
Chuck Norris Rating– hammer lock