The 20 Best Pizza

Fishers, IN, United States

Open map

Fresh reviews:

In April, I spent two weeks in Italy and had pizza 6 times. I hadn’t eaten pizza that many times in 2 years in the US because good pizza can’t be found. Until now, Passione Pane is real authentic Italian pizza, made with fresh ingredients, and the owner is from Italy. Give this place a try, you won’t be…

Craig H.

Passione Pane - Wood-Oven Pizza and Bread

Really great pizza! Fresh and hot delicious tasting ingredients! Cute little environment with chalkboards of the tables I don’t like really greasy pizza and this one is not really Greasy! The cookies are also delicious!

Brenda B.

Brother Doug Pizza

Thin crust pizza was cold, over cooked and burnt crust. So gross. Can’t believe I spent $ 28 plus tip on «the deal» plus a small pizza. I would have been better off with a $ 1 totinos. At least that would have been hot.–Next day owner contacted me and sent gift certificates to make situation right. Highly…

Shannon C.

Decided to stop in and try this place after passing it by numerous times. I was actually pleasantly surprised with the the taste and quality of the pizza. It reminded me a lot both in style and taste to that of the old Luca Pizza pizza places. Which I used to enjoy. I went for the $ 7.99 one topping carry out…

Jeffrey G.

New York Pizza Garden

To start off it took forever before we saw our server (Adam) and got drinks. Not only that but then they got the drinks wrong. My water wasn’t refilled once. My sister didn’t like her meal at all and we weren’t seen by a manager or anything. Also it took 10 minutes to get some sauce that was supposed to be on…

William J.

34 places in Fishers, ordered by rating:

Passione Pane - Wood-Oven Pizza and Bread

4.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-712-6369
Address:	11640 Brooks School Rd Ste 900

Pizza /

Marco’s Pizza

4.2

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-578-7900
Address:	11689 Olio Rd

Pizza /

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-849-2749
Address:	8594 E 116th St

Pizza / Vegan / Gluten-Free

Rockstone Pizzeria & Pub

4.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-288-9761
Address:	11501 Allisonville Rd

Pizza / Pubs

Bubba’s 33

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-915-7427
Address:	9770 North by NE Blvd

American (Traditional) / Pizza / Burgers

Papa Murphy’s

4.0

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-579-7272
Address:	11805 Allisonville Rd

Pizza /

Wise Guys Pizza

4.3

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-915-8202
Address:	11005 Allisonville Rd

Pizza /

Brother Doug Pizza

4.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-565-2704
Address:	11005 Allisonville Rd

Pizza /

Slimms Pizza and Salads

4.0

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 219-869-9869
Address:	7810 E 96th S

Salad / Pizza

Domino’s Pizza

3.4

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-842-3131
Address:	11805 Allisonville Rd

Pizza / Chicken Wings / Sandwiches

Hot Box Pizza

3.7

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-849-4200
Address:	12510 E 116th St

Pizza /

Puccini’s Smiling Teeth

3.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-579-0572
Address:	8993 E 116th St

Italian / Pizza / Gluten-Free

Extreme Pizza

3.7

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-578-8400
Address:	8938 E 96th St

Pizza /

Greek’s Pizzeria

3.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-915-9111
Address:	8800 E 116th St

Pizza /

South of Chicago Pizza & Beef

3.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-219-6039
Address:	13578 E 131st St

Pizza / Sports Bars / Italian

Apezza

3.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-436-8624
Address:	10122 Brooks School Rd

Pizza /

Monical’s Pizza

2.9

19 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-770-8400
Address:	14099 Mundy Dr

Italian / Pizza

New York Pizza Garden

3.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-284-1163
Address:	9522 E 126th St

Pizza /

Firehouse Pizza

3.2

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 317-842-9299
Address:	7261 Fishers Landing Dr

Pizza /

Indianapolis