The Top 20 Auto Repair in Ithaca, NY

Fresh reviews:

Been taking my truck here (1990 Ford F-250) for about a year. Can’t say enough about the service – friendly and honest and thorough. Especially Gary at the desk. Prices are also better than any other garage in town. Place at first seems stuck in the 1970s, but I kind of like that. Makes me feel like I’m right…

Andrew M.

Cole Muffler

I am a repeat customer. These guys care about the work they do. I had my rear rotors and pads replaced about 6 months ago on my Honda CRV. The rotors became warped and they replaced the rotors, with upgraded rotors, at no charge. Honest service and thoughtful concern for customers has always been my experience.

Michael M.

Autoworks

I recently moved from Florida and needed a trustworthy auto shop ASAP. I read the reviews and was sure glad I found this place. I got an oil change, and also had them check out a sound that worried me. I was only charged for the oil change (which was a GREAT price) and the sound was an easy fix (which I didn’t…

Patrick H.

Ithaca Auto Service

Fast, friendly and honest: I had my vehicle come up for its NYS inspection for the first time, so I called Patterson’s to book an appointment. They were entirely professional and courteous throughout the whole process, found a time that suited me, had the work done within 90 minutes and kept me informed of any…

Stephen A.

Patterson’s

I know that many say bad things about Maguire, but I had a great experience! I have been working with both Matt in Trumansburg and Richie in Ithaca for awhile in hopes of trading my 2013 Corvette in on a new Z06. I was able to work on a deal and Richie made sure I received all incentives possible to make the…

Joe R.

Maguire Automotive

I can only write this review through the story told to me by my son in law. He is super fussy about his BMW. These people went out of their way to get a new alternator installed in record time whilst at the same time, giving my wife and him a ride to Cornell on a sick animal mission. Duty above and beyond.

Steve L.

Varna Auto Service

Every time I go there, they say they can’t make appointment for at least three weeks. It seems as though they will never repair your car even when you urgently need their help. I wonder if they will help you if you are their regulars. I have had my car serviced more than a few times there, so I think they…

J K.

Trombley Tire and Auto

37 places in Ithaca, ordered by rating:

Autoworks

5.0

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-277-9989
Address:	1278 Dryden Rd

Auto Repair / Tires

Rt. 13 Tallmadge

4.8

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-391-2220
Address:	358 Elmira Rd Ste 1

Tires / Auto Repair / Auto Parts & Supplies

Ithaca Auto Service

5.0

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-220-9183
Address:	618 Elmira Rd

Auto Repair / Tires / Oil Change Stations

Diane’s Downtown Automotive

4.5

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-272-2886
Address:	435 W State St

Tires / Oil Change Stations / Auto Repair

Trombley Tire and Auto

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-2236
Address:	917 W State St

Tires / Auto Repair

Varna Auto Service

3.9

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-3776
Address:	933 Dryden Rd

Auto Repair /

Ithaca Foreign Car Service

4.1

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-9262
Address:	501 W State St

Auto Repair / Body Shops

Pellegrino’s Saab Service

3.7

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-272-8259
Address:	282 Enfield Main Rd

Auto Repair / Auto Parts & Supplies / Tires

Shade Tree Auto

3.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-277-5959
Address:	1047 Teeter Rd

Auto Repair /

Patterson’s

3.2

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-0322
Address:	221 N Aurora St

Auto Repair / Tires

Maguire Automotive

3.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-257-1515
Address:	370 Elmira Rd

Auto Repair / Car Dealers

Maguire Chevrolet Cadillac

3.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-216-9040
Address:	35 Cinema Dr

Tires / Auto Repair / Car Dealers

Willcox Service & Tire

3.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-6310
Address:	233 Elmira Rd

Tires / Auto Repair

Goodyear Auto Service Center

2.5

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-4580
Address:	411 Elmira Road

Tires / Oil Change Stations / Auto Repair

Pritchard Automotive

2.6

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-272-8822
Address:	304 S Cayuga St

Car Dealers / Body Shops / Auto Repair

Maguire Ford Nissan

2.3

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-272-8000
Address:	504 South Meadow St

Auto Repair / Car Dealers

Honda of Ithaca

2.7

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-1926
Address:	315 Elmira Rd

Auto Repair / Car Dealers

Mavis Discount Tire

2.6

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-330-9998
Address:	231 Elmira Rd

Auto Repair / Oil Change Stations / Tires

Monro Muffler Brake & Service

1.4

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-8600
Address:	338 Elmira Road

Tires / Auto Repair / Oil Change Stations

Midas

1.2

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-272-6312
Address:	347 Elmira Road

Auto Repair / Oil Change Stations / Tires

The Top 20 Auto Repair

Ithaca, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

37 places in Ithaca, ordered by rating: